Prime ODLH beats Manny and floyd

[Kev]

What weight would these fights be taking place at?

Manny vs Oscar at lightweight would be interesting, Floyd vs Oscar at light welter too.

Id pick Manny and Floyd.

If you want to put Oscar in the welterweight or light middle divisions however I think he wouldnt be fighting the best Floyd or Manny either.

its impossible to put them both in the ring in their primes and prime weights as they are different sized fighters......

[Taeth]

any arguments? i think he would kick their ass, this coming from a huge floyd maywaether fan and manny fan

Oscar didn't beat legit ATG's, he was notch below them, and these are two very highly ranked all-time greats. Oscar was a great fighter, but not quite on their level.

A younger Oscar was faster than the one that fought Floyd, but not as big and strong. Also when he was younger he tried to box with guys more, and the more he would try and straight up box with Mayweather the worse he would lose. The reason why he did as well as he did was experience and wisdom. He did his best to corner and contain Mayweather. A younger Oscar would have tried to play the speed game with Floyd, and also try to knock him out which would have resulted in Oscar getting outboxed, and tiring earlier in the fight.

As for Manny, there is now no evidence for me to believe that Oscar could hurt Manny with any one big punch. Sure it could happen, but once again I see Manny being to fluid offensively and too fast for Oscar. Oscar would obviously be more competitive than the weight drained version we saw face Manny, but besides his jab and occasional left hook I don't see him having enough weapons to outdo Manny's arsenal for 12 rounds.