Is It Time For James Toney To Hang The Gloves Up

[Trainer Monkey]

Based on that
Pack it in
Guys a tomato,and for most of the round,Toney cant get off first
Hes never had true heavyweight power,and now its looking like he no longer has cruiserweight speed
But again,that just basing it off of that footage,so he might have been on cruise control for that round

[Gandalf]

Based on that I need to see Toney fight 1 more time and hopefully in front of more cameras. That footage was not vintage Toney, but it did look like a bout of habitual sparring...

Hopefully Toney sticks to his word and is back very soon...

[BoomBoom]

Toneys not really a shot fighter, hes just not a heavyweight. He thinks that his skills alone are enough for him to suceed at this weight. That is the problem with Toney and he wont fix it this far along so yes he should retire, but he wont.

[OumaFan]

I wouldn't mind if he retired, I haven't seen this fight so I can't say much about it but before this fight I thought it might be the right move to go ahead and retire.

Is he gonna get better, he's just getting older, who really thinks he's gonna get down to 215, even 220? It'd be great to see him come back and win a big fight but he's gonna end up having fought on to long probably.