Pacquaio vs. Casamayor? Who wins?

[Taeth]

I'm not sure, and I won't share my opinion on this anyways, but who do you guys feels wins this at lightweight.

[babyboNe]

taeth, this is another pacman vs. whoever match...this is sh1t, (huge fart)

but I`d love to see it whoever wins it`ll be great.

[Violent Demise]

Casamayor by 5th round knock out

[Taeth]

taeth, this is another pacman vs. whoever match...this is sh1t, (huge fart)

but I`d love to see it whoever wins it`ll be great.

No I'm over that, I am actually asking.

[Violent Demise]

taeth, this is another pacman vs. whoever match...this is sh1t, (huge fart)

but I`d love to see it whoever wins it`ll be great.

No I'm over that, I am actually asking.

Casamayor by 5th round knock out

[Rotten Apple]

I can see Casamayor winning. But I don\'t think it\'s by stoppage

[pacfan]

Hahaaa, it's another of those fan's wishful thinking thread. Let me give you mine. Well, maybe I don't need to. Casamayor answered that himself. He called out Pac when he was 126lbs, saying he was willing to come down to 130 from 135 just to 'accomodate' Pac. But when Pac beat Erik, he said Pac was a flyweight stick or something and instead called out on ol' Barrera to fight him. Hmmm, that's kinda strange, 126lb Pac good for him but 130lb Pac too small for him? what does that mean... I think Mr. Violent D will give you the answer.

[El Gamo]

At 135,Cas allll the way. At 130,Manny may be....Pacquiao is a monster at 130,and Cas i getting ol,making that weight would be hard for him. 135,I think Cas would really outfox and outbox him.Joel is one of the most unfer rated fighters i the game today and had he had a bit of luck with decisions,the guys would be unbeaten and P4P top 5 EASILY.H;es been in soooooo many close fights!

[pacfan]

I'm pretty sure my man El Gamo knows his stuff so that's a CC for you. But I hope that won't happen though.

[El Gamo]

CC back bro. I just think Joel at 135 would be too big for Manny and for allllll of Manny's many many improvements,his balance is still off when he throws punches and Casamayor is slick. He'd make Manny miss,land a punch or a combo and he would be out of there again. Also,at 135,Joel took Diego Corrales best punches and I think Corrales hits harder than Pacman,certainly with 1 punch.

I'd like to see Pacman fight a natural 130 pounder later this year,Edwin Valero.

[Taeth]

Size isn't such a big factor IMO because Pacquaio came in at 144 like I said before and was tight... He could easily weigh 160 walking around IMO, and could put on a good 5-10 more pounds in the ring of muscle before it becomes excessive.

[Violent Demise]

Hahaaa, it's another of those fan's wishful thinking thread. Let me give you mine. Well, maybe I don't need to. Casamayor answered that himself. He called out Pac when he was 126lbs, saying he was willing to come down to 130 from 135 just to 'accomodate' Pac. But when Pac beat Erik, he said Pac was a flyweight stick or something and instead called out on ol' Barrera to fight him. Hmmm, that's kinda strange, 126lb Pac good for him but 130lb Pac too small for him? what does that mean... I think Mr. Violent D will give you the answer.

That's cuz when Casamayor called out Pac the first time Freddie Roach quickly shot down that idea saying Casamayor was to big. What's the point of calling out a fighter who don't want to fight? Casamayor is the Ring recognized Lightweight champion. Yet you never hear Pac call him out. I wonder why?

[babyboNe]

Size isn't such a big factor IMO because Pacquaio came in at 144 like I said before and was tight... He could easily weigh 160 walking around IMO, and could put on a good 5-10 more pounds in the ring of muscle before it becomes excessive.

cc taeth, good point. size will always be the reason doubters will say why pac can't win though. because 130 maybe his limit, his gone up enough in most peoples oppinion. when he went up to 126 mab was his first oppenent, pac had no problem his speed power and stamina followed right with him coming up. but when he came up to 130 his first fight was eric, pacs speed stamina and power didn't follow him up right away, but to be fair to pac, right before that fight with eric, they drained blood from him, he had the whole camotion with his promotion and add to that his power was a bit cussion by the gloves erics camp trick him to use, yea a bunch of excuse, but those are facts, so they could of really played a big part why pac coming up to 130 for the first time wasn't so smooth unlike the other times he came up.

before everyone said pacs best weight is 126, but now nobody says that because clearly pacs power speed and stamina has arrive with pac at 130 and pac has added more arsenal, his no longer one demensional, and his defense is underrated, anyone can say what they want, but mab em and jmm had a hard time hitting him as much as they are use to hitting there oppenents, his fast and now counters with head and body movement plus he anticipate punches coming.

I think 135 is pacs limit, but I hope he cleans up 130 before going up, mab jmm guzman valero. all of them pac can and will ktfo.

[Lords Gym]

Joel Casamyor is not all that good . Pacman would blitz his ass something fierce. IMO

[Taeth]

Casamayor isn't all that good? I believe he may have lost once to Diego, and that was a close fihgt, but IMO he beat Castillo, and beat Diego twice, and I'm not sure, but didn't he win an olympic gold? He has a good chin, power, speed, and skill. So does Pacquaio, except for a chin, but its decent, and he has better speed than Casamayor at this point in their careers.