SHOULD Chuck Giampa BE BLACKLISTED?

[SalTheButcher]

not only did he give taylor that fight by 2 points (115-113)...


-----
2004-04-10 Cory Spinks W Zab Judah -- Judge: Chuck Giampa 114-112 (spinks)
-----
1994-01-29 Julio Cesar Chavez L Frankie Randall -- Judge: Chuck Giampa 111-116 (rhandall)
-----
2005-12-03 Jermain Taylor W Bernard Hopkins -- Judge: Chuck Giampa 115-113 (taylor)
-----
2000-10-07 Paulie Ayala W Johnny Tapia -- Judge: Chuck Giampa 115-113 (ayala)

[albsur2006]

I really don't know what fight some of you were watching, this was so obviously a draw or a Taylor win.

[SalTheButcher]

I really don't know what fight some of you were watching, this was so obviously a draw or a Taylor win.

SINCE WHEN DOES HITTING SOMEONES GLOVES COUNT AS A CLEAN PUNCH!!?!?!?!?!!!

[albsur2006]

Yeah, it was those punches on the gloves that were backing Winky up. Taylor hit gloves a lot but he also landed cleanly and around the ear. Don't blame it on the judge, blame Winky for running like ODLH in the 12th.

[SalTheButcher]

Yeah, it was those punches on the gloves that were backing Winky up. Taylor hit gloves a lot but he also landed cleanly and around the ear. Don't blame it on the judge, blame Winky for running like ODLH in the 12th.

he didnt run like ODH, he outlanded taylor

[Mad_Dog]

what do you call a dog with no legs and steel testicles?












sparky






true

[Wacko3205]

Yeah, it was those punches on the gloves that were backing Winky up. Taylor hit gloves a lot but he also landed cleanly and around the ear. Don't blame it on the judge, blame Winky for running like ODLH in the 12th.

Watch the 12th again...Winky was the one landing the punches. Taylor missed & still got the 12th round.

Don't blame it on Winky when it was clearly his round.

[SalTheButcher]

what do you call a dog with no legs and steel testicles?

sparky

true

[Wacko3205]

I voted NO.

[SalTheButcher]

I voted NO.

[SalTheButcher]

i will respect the outcome of the poll

[Jody Lane]

I voted NO.

me too

[Purist]

I voted YES anyone that says Ayala beat Tapia has no business judging

I dont know how Taylor hits Winky once(being generous) in the 12th and gets the 12th. And takes a beating from Bernard in the 12th and still gets the 12th. 12 seems to be Jermain's lucky number.. and thats how much longer he'll b champ. 12 months

[amat]

Yeah, it was those punches on the gloves that were backing Winky up. Taylor hit gloves a lot but he also landed cleanly and around the ear. Don't blame it on the judge, blame Winky for running like ODLH in the 12th.

Backing Winky up? Umm...no he was never backed up. And Winky ran for the last 30 seconds after a dominant two minutes. He won the round, no way it should ever be scored for Taylor.

[Lords Gym]

I had the fight 115-113 Taylor also, Great fight !