Thread: Scoring for both the Campillio and Klitschko fights at the weekend

As some know , i write a blog collecting fight scores from the fans and press etc (can be viewed in the signature below).

This week we had our first big controversial decision in the Cloud vs Campillio fight as the Texan judges robbed the Spanaird of his 2nd world title. I scored the fight 114-112 , it was a close fight although i dont think it was a massive robbery.

Most fans and press who scored this fight had Campillio winning by either 114-112 or 115-111 , i mention in my blog that IF the 115-111 (from 114-112) score has a one point swing the other way then its a 113-113 fight.

A few had it a draw and only 1 had the fight to Cloud...by a massive 118-111 , i know they must be having a laugh.

Regarding the Klitscho vs Chisora fight , this was an easier fight to score as most fans and press had big Vitali winning 117-111 or 116-112 but as we all know the fight has been overshadowed by the post fight brawl between Chisora and Haye.

Thanks to all teh fans who put in their score but also to the press members who tool the time to contact me , some of the boxing names who contacted me where..Al Bernstein , Nigel Collins , Thomas Hauser , Tris Dixion , Glyn Leach , Gab Montoya , Steve Kim and many more

check out their scores too below in the signature.

ps: cheers to Ouma fan for your help

Always interesting to see -- thanks for this.

I must say I have no idea how you could score round 2 for Cloud though -- he got pretty thoroughly dominated in that round. And I don't think it's true that a 114-112 fight can't be a robbery. If there is no possible way of legitimately giving Cloud another round (and IMO, there isn't -- I can't even see giving him 4 rounds personally), then it's a clear error to score it a draw. And a robbery to actually score the fight for Cloud, which was the end result.

Originally Posted by shza

Always interesting to see -- thanks for this.

I must say I have no idea how you could score round 2 for Cloud though -- he got pretty thoroughly dominated in that round. And I don't think it's true that a 114-112 fight can't be a robbery. If there is no possible way of legitimately giving Cloud another round (and IMO, there isn't -- I can't even see giving him 4 rounds personally), then it's a clear error to score it a draw. And a robbery to actually score the fight for Cloud, which was the end result.

This, if you can't find another round to legitimately give to cloud its basically a robbery, doesn't matter if its just one point...

Originally Posted by fightscorecollector

As some know , i write a blog collecting fight scores from the fans and press etc (can be viewed in the signature below).

This week we had our first big controversial decision in the Cloud vs Campillio fight as the Texan judges robbed the Spanaird of his 2nd world title. I scored the fight 114-112 , it was a close fight although i dont think it was a massive robbery.

Most fans and press who scored this fight had Campillio winning by either 114-112 or 115-111 , i mention in my blog that IF the 115-111 (from 114-112) score has a one point swing the other way then its a 113-113 fight.

A few had it a draw and only 1 had the fight to Cloud...by a massive 118-111 , i know they must be having a laugh.

Regarding the Klitscho vs Chisora fight , this was an easier fight to score as most fans and press had big Vitali winning 117-111 or 116-112 but as we all know the fight has been overshadowed by the post fight brawl between Chisora and Haye.

Thanks to all teh fans who put in their score but also to the press members who tool the time to contact me , some of the boxing names who contacted me where..Al Bernstein , Nigel Collins , Thomas Hauser , Tris Dixion , Glyn Leach , Gab Montoya , Steve Kim and many more

check out their scores too below in the signature.

ps: cheers to Ouma fan for your help

Keep up the good work on the blog. It fills a much-needed void of keeping track of boxing decisions.

Originally Posted by Rantcatrat

Originally Posted by fightscorecollector

As some know , i write a blog collecting fight scores from the fans and press etc (can be viewed in the signature below).

This week we had our first big controversial decision in the Cloud vs Campillio fight as the Texan judges robbed the Spanaird of his 2nd world title. I scored the fight 114-112 , it was a close fight although i dont think it was a massive robbery.

Most fans and press who scored this fight had Campillio winning by either 114-112 or 115-111 , i mention in my blog that IF the 115-111 (from 114-112) score has a one point swing the other way then its a 113-113 fight.

A few had it a draw and only 1 had the fight to Cloud...by a massive 118-111 , i know they must be having a laugh.

Regarding the Klitscho vs Chisora fight , this was an easier fight to score as most fans and press had big Vitali winning 117-111 or 116-112 but as we all know the fight has been overshadowed by the post fight brawl between Chisora and Haye.

Thanks to all teh fans who put in their score but also to the press members who tool the time to contact me , some of the boxing names who contacted me where..Al Bernstein , Nigel Collins , Thomas Hauser , Tris Dixion , Glyn Leach , Gab Montoya , Steve Kim and many more

check out their scores too below in the signature.

ps: cheers to Ouma fan for your help

Keep up the good work on the blog. It fills a much-needed void of keeping track of boxing decisions.

Agreed, I'd be willing to extrapolate the data sometimes if you'd like.

I had it 115-113 and Hulk had it a draw, where did you get the saddo scores from?

Originally Posted by Master

I had it 115-113 and Hulk had it a draw, where did you get the saddo scores from?

Alright mate , i got the scores on Saddo from this thread.

http://www.saddoboxing.com/boxingfor...-campillo.html

Originally Posted by fightscorecollector

Originally Posted by Master

I had it 115-113 and Hulk had it a draw, where did you get the saddo scores from?

Alright mate , i got the scores on Saddo from this thread.

http://www.saddoboxing.com/boxingfor...-campillo.html

OK next time I will put the Cleverly score on the Povetkin thread.