Scoring for both the Campillio and Klitschko fights at the weekend

[shza]

Always interesting to see -- thanks for this.

I must say I have no idea how you could score round 2 for Cloud though -- he got pretty thoroughly dominated in that round. And I don't think it's true that a 114-112 fight can't be a robbery. If there is no possible way of legitimately giving Cloud another round (and IMO, there isn't -- I can't even see giving him 4 rounds personally), then it's a clear error to score it a draw. And a robbery to actually score the fight for Cloud, which was the end result.

[armin]

Always interesting to see -- thanks for this.

I must say I have no idea how you could score round 2 for Cloud though -- he got pretty thoroughly dominated in that round. And I don't think it's true that a 114-112 fight can't be a robbery. If there is no possible way of legitimately giving Cloud another round (and IMO, there isn't -- I can't even see giving him 4 rounds personally), then it's a clear error to score it a draw. And a robbery to actually score the fight for Cloud, which was the end result.

This, if you can't find another round to legitimately give to cloud its basically a robbery, doesn't matter if its just one point...