Who is the next boxing superstar?

[ross]

The young, dedicated and focused 80s Tyson is a completely different proposition.

You mean the Tyson that was fighting such dangerous foes as Mike Jameson, David Jaco, Sammy Scaff, Marvis Frazier, and Steve Zouski?

Oh dear.

Hell, let's throw Tyson's amateur opponents in there as well shall we? How far back in time are going? What about before he started boxing? He hadn't beaten anyone then!

I was (obviously) thinking of the Tyson who beat everyone he fought, including Holmes, Spinks, Biggs etc etc. But no, let's judge him on the guys he fought as an up and coming novice. That always how fighters are judged.

I mean that Ali guy was good, but who did he beat in his first ten fights? Overrated fraud!

Can you expound on the "etc., etc.," I challenge you or anyone else on this forum to name elite, HOF level fighters that Tyson beat. Look at the three you named: Holmes was past his best and fighting without a tune up, Spinks who was a great light heavy but undersized at heavy n had beaten 3 other guys at the weight, and BIGGS. Tyrell Biggs?!? Here's a clue: when you are standing up for a guy's quality of opposition and you have to include Tyrell Biggs as one of his top 3 wins, don't send that post. I like Mike Tyson and I think he gets treated unfairly regarding his personal life, but zit is just a known fact that Mike feasted on a pathetic division. He never beat a prime fighter on the level of Evander, Bowe, Lewis, Wlad...etc.

You could easily pick holes over who they beat.

Which elite HOF fighters did Lewis beat? He drew with Holyfield and then got gifted a decision in the rematch. Struggled with Mercer and was very lucky to get the decision. Holmes won clearly against mercer. The same Holmes that Tyson smashed 4 years earlier. He got knocked out by mikes sparring partner the same sparring partner that again, Holmes should have got a decision over. he got knocked out by Rahman

Holyfield... Bowe? Who did Bowe beat? He got pushed to 12 rounds by a fighter that Mike bounced off the canvas

Bowe... Holyfield and no one else. He got battered by golota who Tyson made quit! He got taken rounds and hurt by Herbie Hide He was gifted a decision against Tubbs another old Tyson opponent who Mike wiped the floor with.

Now tell me the best wins each of those has and how its any better than anything Mike could have done.

Wlads best win? He's up there for longevity but he has no HOF stand out wins either. That shouldnt detract from his career because there was no one else good enough to beat him. (Has plenty of KO losses during his "prime" though.) Same as Mike in the eighties. He was too good. He didn't get dropped, or wobbled or draw, or gifted decisions. There was no dispute over who the best was and he avoided no one in the top ten.