De La Hoya: Pacquiao makes fighters lose on the scales 1st

[Hornfinger]

After 10 pages the fact remains the same.


If a couple of pounds under the weight limit makes no difference to a fighters performance on the night, why would pacroid, and his team of gay homo erotic cheating drug dealers, insist on the catch weight or lower weightclass?
,
If it made no difference Pacroid would have fought DLH at 154, Cotto at 147, Margarito at 154.

Who has said it made no difference? We are saying that being weight drained was not a factor.

There are many people on here arguing that if Marquez is to fight Manny the fight shouldn't be above 140 because Marquez doesn't carry the weight as well as Manny, and that it is fairer to fight at junior welter than welter as Marquez is not a welterweight.

The argument isn't that Manny will be weight drained at 140, he could make the weight no problem. It's just that he is suited to a lower weight class.

Well it's the same for Manny. Manny is not nearly as big as Antonio Margarito, and is considerably smaller than Miguel Cotto also. He's NOT a junior middleweight. He entered the ring against Margarito weighing 148lbs, compared to Margarito's 165.

If it wasn't a catchweight Margarito would have likely entered the ring at 170. That would be a 22lb weight advantage. That's a big difference!

How can you not see this? When two guys are different sizes they have find somewhere to meet, a weight to fight at. Against Cotto it was agreed 145, against Margarito it was agreed 150. You could make exactly the same argument for fighting Cotto at full welter, why not at 154? And why not fight Margarito at 160?

The higher they go the more it favours the bigger man because Manny isn't gaining weight. He's being massively outweighed.

I've said it many times but I will reiterate it. Your posts are ridiculous.

i don't really care that a joke like you thinks my posts are rediculous. I wouldn't even regard you as a boxing fan because from what I've read you have no clue what your talking about and the fact this post i'm replying to is you running around chasing your tale shows that.

Now I'm going to rip your moronic post apart.....

Who has said it made no difference? We are saying that being weight drained was not a factor.

Right there is a huge contradiction. Weight is a factor and does make a difference but weight drainage wasn't a factor. And my posts are rediculous? Yours are just all out dumb.

You're now saying dropping down the weight does make a difference and so pac is trying to weaken his opponants before getting in the ring. I thought you disagreed with me mr dildo? It seems you don't know which side of the arguement you're on

There are many people on here arguing that if Marquez is to fight Manny the fight shouldn't be above 140 because Marquez doesn't carry the weight as well as Manny, and that it is fairer to fight at junior welter than welter as Marquez is not a welterweight.

Again this is something that I have been saying. Manny has never made 147 on the scales at a weigh in, neither has marquez so why fight at 147? Again I thought you were arguing with my rediculous post? you're agreeing with them.

The argument isn't that Manny will be weight drained at 140, he could make the weight no problem. It's just that he is suited to a lower weight class.

The thread title, must I remind you is 'De La Hoya: Pacquiao makes fighters lose on the scales 1st'

No one is saying Manny Pacquiao will be drained at 140. the thread is if Manny Pacquioa beat ODH, Cotto and margarito legitly. And the answer is no because in each fight he either made his opponant go down to an unattainable weight class or fight them at a catch weight. And as you said in your first sentance of this moronic post 'no one has said it made no difference.'

TBH I actually feel like I'm explaining this to a retarded child....

Well it's the same for Manny. Manny is not nearly as big as Antonio Margarito, and is considerably smaller than Miguel Cotto also. He's NOT a junior middleweight. He entered the ring against Margarito weighing 148lbs, compared to Margarito's 165.

SO DON'T TAKE THE FIGHT!

If you can't fight Antonio Margarito at 154 then don't get in the ring with him. If you're not a junior middle weight DON'T FIGHT FOR THE FUCKING JUNIOR MIDDLE WEIGHT TITLE! It's that simple. Cotto fights at 147 for a reason. That's the weight he fights best at. Not a pound below. Manny and his team knew that and thats why they made the catch weight.

Honestly Dildo are you fucking thick as pig shit? By the way that's rhetorical.

If it wasn't a catchweight Margarito would have likely entered the ring at 170. That would be a 22lb weight advantage. That's a big difference!

SEE ABOVE.

And why would Toni have entered at 170? because that's what his body naturally goes to function at. If Toni is normally around 170 in the ring but wasn't for the pacroid fight that tells me one thing. He was weight drained due to making the catch weight.

Many fighters have entered the ring with their opponant weighing 22 pounds + heavier and they've gone on and won the fight.

AGAIN IF YOU CAN'T HANDLE THE WEIGHT PARAMATERS OF A DIVISION DON'T FIGHT THERE!

How can you not see this? When two guys are different sizes they have find somewhere to meet, a weight to fight at. Against Cotto it was agreed 145, against Margarito it was agreed 150. You could make exactly the same argument for fighting Cotto at full welter, why not at 154? And why not fight Margarito at 160?

This is rediculously silly. Every year fighters move up weight classes with no monaing complaining or catch weights.

If you can't compete at the higher weight class because the fighters up there are 'too big' then don't go up there.

HOW CAN YOU NOT SEE THAT!?

The higher they go the more it favours the bigger man because Manny isn't gaining weight. He's being massively outweighed.

THEN HE SHOULDN'T FIGHT AT THAT WEIGHT (how many times have I said that now? are you getting the message yet?)

I've said it many times but I will reiterate it. Your posts are ridiculous.