It was sold way past it's expiration date. Both guys were divas and couldn't get the fight made when it mattered, and the fight they had was just a consolation prize.

That being said, I doubt the fight in 2010 would have been much different. Floyd would have won in anti-climactic fashion. It was destined to be a lackluster affair, because Manny was so fast and dangerous that Floyd would have always fought conservative as possible.