Originally Posted by
Violent Demise
Yamanaka drops 2 spots after winning a fight? Really? I had Moreno beating Yamanaka as well. But I thought the fight was competitive and don't consider it a robbery. And defitnaly don't think he should of dropped from the top spot. Moreno deserved to move up. But not to the top spot
I agonized over that decision. On one hand I had Moreno winning handily. Yamanaka had entered at #1 so Moreno should advance over him.
McDonnell has also been on an excellent run so should he be demoted because of Yamanaka's performance? I didn't think that would be fair.
I also had to consider that to fill the vacant championship at this weight a fight would have to involve Moreno (seeing as I saw him beating the top guy). Leaving Yamanaka at #1 and McDonnell second would seem unfair if that fight was made to crown a champion, when I had scored 116-112 for Moreno over Yamanaka.
As it stands the championship can only be filled in a fight involving Moreno. If he fights #2 McDonnell or possibly if he fights a rematch with Yamanaka.
At the end of the day I saw Moreno winning clearly so that is indicated in the rankings.
Thanks: 
Likes: 
Dislikes: 
Re: SugarJ's World Boxing Rankings
Reply With Quote
Bookmarks