What will Clinch-ko's legacy be?

[TitoFan]

No Joe Frazier didn't change his style, he was 29 years old and a pressure fighter....he wasn't going to be able to change his style.

Yes, he was 29 when he got KTFO'ed by Foreman. Wlad was 28 when he got KTFO'ed by Brewster. I don't get your fucking point but ok... you're Lyle, so obviously you're right. Frazier wasn't going to be able to change his style because........ oh...... because he was a "pressure fighter"? Good reason.

Frazier continued his storied career, and even had the aforementioned Thrilla in Manila later on. Wlad turned into Bambi from there on out. Nothing you said explains away this disparity.

Objection OVERRULED.

Ali changed HIS style in order to what was that you said "to one of survival over aggression" but that's no biggie, it's Ali and not 1 bad word will be said about HIM. Sure you see Ali vs Williams and see your float like a butterfly sting like a bee, then you see Ali-Foreman and it's lay on the ropes like you're tired and arm punch like a bee....but oh Ali was the greatest and totally not because he just said that shit himself

Yes.... (sigh)..... Ali changed his style, Lyle. You get a happy face for your notebook. (patiently)..... Ali changed his style, but he remained an effective, aggressive fighter. The rope-a-dope against Foreman? He was facing the most feared puncher probably in HW history, the one who had pulverized Frazier previously. Ali didn't throw himself shamelessly on top of Foreman the way Wlad did with Povetkin. Ali employed a strategy whereby he waited till Foreman tired himself out, then knocked him out.

"Lennox Lewis avenged his defeats".....Wlad beat Lamon Brewster and what? Nothing he gets nothing for that? No "Atta boy" no "Way to be champ" Haha, only Wlad can do that avenge a defeat and then STILL have you bring up "Well Lennox avenged his defeats" like Wlad has done absolutely nothing....Wlad got up off the canvas to win a fight, Lennox ever do that? But naaah, that's no big deal no need to be handing Wlad any credit because you thoroughly dislike the guy.....fine, dislike away, enjoy your disliking.

Atta boy.

Tyson didn't change his style.....oh really? Well then you must be the fucking first person to ever admit that because if you ask a Tyson fan about him there's no better Tyson than Tyson with Cus or Rooney and anything else is not Tyson in his prime.

This was your most hilarious response.
I speak of Tyson not changing his style and you respond that people say that Tyson with Cus was better and anything else is not Tyson in his prime?!?

Hello? Habla español?? Sprichst du Deutsch??

I like it better when we debate something and you actually make sense, TBH.


I hate to put it this way, because it IS going to sound patronizing and condescending, but I'll try to be gentle.

Changing one's style has fuck all to do with how good you happen to be at whatever point in time, or not. They're two separate issues.

Comprende?

[El Kabong]

Tito, pressure fighters don't change their stripes. Now with Wlad you had a big guy, a big puncher, what did he lack? A chin, some defense, you patch together a style that works for him and boom you can change him. What was Frazier going to do? Was Joe Frazier going to use his height on Foreman? Was Joe going to use a different defense against Foreman? I mean you tell me, I've not really ever seen a pressure fighter be anything other than a pressure fighter. If a fighter's mentality is to move the hands, attack attack attack, then it's going to take some time to slow them down, have them think defense first at times. Imagine this, imagine Mike Tyson had to change his style, what would you end up with? It wouldn't be Pernell Whittaker, it wouldn't be Lennox Lewis, MAYBE you could get him to fight more like Holyfield, but at the end of the day 100% of Pressure fighters who can punch with power end up like David Tua and the Pressure fighters without power.....well they don't last very long. Joe Frazier never won another meaningful fight, oooh he and Ali beat the piss out of each other in Manilla, whoopty do...Frazier lost yet again to Foreman right after that as well....didn't make any progress did he? Meanwhile Wlad, looking like the career is over at 28 gets back in the saddle and runs off a streak of wins which is HISTORIC...but ok, I get it, you don't like him, don't like his style....and here I was thinking that the objective was to win fights.


Ali was yes EFFECTIVE, yes maybe even AGGRESSIVE....fun to watch? For you maybe, but not for me. Leaning on the ropes, holding the head of his opponent down with both arms....illegal or do we just notice that when Wlad has a clinch? Wlad never held an opponent down like Ali did, Wlad would tie up and walk back, but that's about it.


Take your atta boy and fuck off it's like 10 years too late for that shit


See again my point about pressure fighters not changing their styles...Tyson was what he was, the was nothing else you were going to do to better the guy. Manny Steward made Wlad a smarter and therefore BETTER fighter. Wlad could have fought his career the way he fought early on as a pro, but had he done so he wouldn't have been as dominant because there's no guarantee that he'd be able to KO everyone he fought, plus he'd be giving up his most useful advantages in his height and reach....he won belts with the previous style, he became GREAT after Steward coached him up. Could he have been better? As in better for the fans to watch? Yeah, he probably could have...but could the results have been better? You'd be very hard pressed to answer in the affirmative there.



You don't appreciate Wlad, I get it, I think we ALL get it....totally fine....but he's still an All-Time great fighter, you don't get his record without being great, you don't win as many title fights, you don't get as many title fights, you don't reign for that long without being a GREAT fighter....doesn't matter who you face either. Larry Holmes got beat by a light heavyweight for fucks sake and he's a great fighter.

[TitoFan]

Tito, pressure fighters don't change their stripes. Now with Wlad you had a big guy, a big puncher, what did he lack? A chin, some defense, you patch together a style that works for him and boom you can change him. What was Frazier going to do? Was Joe Frazier going to use his height on Foreman? Was Joe going to use a different defense against Foreman? I mean you tell me, I've not really ever seen a pressure fighter be anything other than a pressure fighter. If a fighter's mentality is to move the hands, attack attack attack, then it's going to take some time to slow them down, have them think defense first at times. Imagine this, imagine Mike Tyson had to change his style, what would you end up with? It wouldn't be Pernell Whittaker, it wouldn't be Lennox Lewis, MAYBE you could get him to fight more like Holyfield, but at the end of the day 100% of Pressure fighters who can punch with power end up like David Tua and the Pressure fighters without power.....well they don't last very long. Joe Frazier never won another meaningful fight, oooh he and Ali beat the piss out of each other in Manilla, whoopty do...Frazier lost yet again to Foreman right after that as well....didn't make any progress did he? Meanwhile Wlad, looking like the career is over at 28 gets back in the saddle and runs off a streak of wins which is HISTORIC...but ok, I get it, you don't like him, don't like his style....and here I was thinking that the objective was to win fights.

Of all those mentioned, I'll give you Frazier as a no-way-no-how he could've ever changed his style no matter what. He only had the one gear... forward... throwing hooks and punches in bunches. The others are not good examples to try to make a case for Wlad. Ali changed his style to adapt to his changing body and to age. But he never fought scared of getting hit. He merely used different tactics to minimize whatever blows he did take. Lennox got KTFO'ed just as bad as Wlad did. Now Lennox was not a pressure fighter, was he. He was more comparable to Wlad than either Frazier or Tyson. So how did Lennox react to getting KTFO'ed? Did he crawl into a defensive shell, caring only about protecting his chin and if the knockout victory happened to come he'd welcome it? NO. He made whatever adjustments he felt were necessary, and continued his long and successful career. Your smug last comment notwithstanding, yes... the objective is to win fights. But boxing also aspires to attract fans, does it not? Quit saying "YOU don't like him." It almost sounds like I'm the lonely voice in the planet criticizing Wlad, when you know full well even most of the forum totally dislikes his style. So news flash: It's not just TitoFan.

Ali was yes EFFECTIVE, yes maybe even AGGRESSIVE....fun to watch? For you maybe, but not for me. Leaning on the ropes, holding the head of his opponent down with both arms....illegal or do we just notice that when Wlad has a clinch? Wlad never held an opponent down like Ali did, Wlad would tie up and walk back, but that's about it.

"Fun to watch"..... ahhh, yes. Yes or no answers, please: Was Wlad-Povetkin fun to watch? Was Wlad-Sultan? Was Wlad-Fury? Was Wlad-Haye?
No further questions, your Honor.

"Wlad never held an opponent down like Ali did"??!?? I had to reread that several times, cause I refused to believe I was reading correctly.
I went back and rewatched lowlights of the Wlad-Povetkin fight not long ago.
From the very get-go Wlad launches himself shamelessly onto Povetkin's back.
He proceeds to this over and over and over and over and over again.
What was it? Over 180 times, to be exact?
I'm talking LAUNCHES himself. Reaching out with both hands, grabbing Povetkin around the back of the neck, and putting his entire body weight on Povetkin's back.
NOW.... before you regurgitate the line of "well the ref didn't call it"...... does the ref not calling it make it more fun to watch??
No further questions, your Honor.

We'll just make believe you never said that.

Take your atta boy and fuck off it's like 10 years too late for that shit

C'mon Lyle..... didn't my sincerity just ooze out of that "atta boy"?

See again my point about pressure fighters not changing their styles...Tyson was what he was, the was nothing else you were going to do to better the guy. Manny Steward made Wlad a smarter and therefore BETTER fighter. Wlad could have fought his career the way he fought early on as a pro, but had he done so he wouldn't have been as dominant because there's no guarantee that he'd be able to KO everyone he fought, plus he'd be giving up his most useful advantages in his height and reach....he won belts with the previous style, he became GREAT after Steward coached him up. Could he have been better? As in better for the fans to watch? Yeah, he probably could have...but could the results have been better? You'd be very hard pressed to answer in the affirmative there.

Most people say Tyson was better when Cus D'Amato was in his life and career. So theoretically if another Cus had shown up in Tyson's life and career after the original Cus died and Tyson picked up all sorts of nasty habits..... no, I don't agree there "was nothing else you could do to better the guy." Furthermore, you're making the HUGE assumption that the only way Wlad could've improved was by adopting the style he adopted. You're for some reason shutting the door on the slight possibility that Wlad could've been coached to correct his deficiencies WITHOUT giving up his height and reach advantages. That's an assumption that you're free to make, but nobody is forced to agree with.

You don't appreciate Wlad, I get it, I think we ALL get it....totally fine....but he's still an All-Time great fighter, you don't get his record without being great, you don't win as many title fights, you don't get as many title fights, you don't reign for that long without being a GREAT fighter....doesn't matter who you face either. Larry Holmes got beat by a light heavyweight for fucks sake and he's a great fighter.

Know what? I'm not arguing that Wlad isn't a great fighter. Stunned?

What I've been arguing since Day One is that by Wlad adopting the style he did for the rest of his career, he cheated boxing fans of watching a great HW champion ply his skills in the way all HW heavyweight champions have done so in the past..... with honor and dignity. Not by cheating his way through a lot of his fights. Not by fighting Fury like Bambi up against a big bad logger with a chainsaw. Only in this case the chainsaw was turned off... and Bambi and the logger did a 12-round contest of who can throw the least amount of punches.



So remain on your immense soapbox... and continue thinking that it's just TitoFan who hates Wlad.
Meanwhile I'll continue pointing out all kinds of facts to you.

Hmm... maybe I'm just meaner in the way I do it.

[vidgil]

I don't think there's anything wrong with saying Wlad fought like a big sissy!

[Master]

I don't think there's anything wrong with saying Wlad fought like a big sissy!

If Wlad beats AJ, his legacy will be greatly enhanced as he has come back from a loss and beat a young, undefeated and hungry champion who has stopped all his opponents within 7 rounds. Easily top 10 on the list of heavyweight champions.

[TitoFan]

I don't think there's anything wrong with saying Wlad fought like a big sissy!

If Wlad beats AJ, his legacy will be greatly enhanced as he has come back from a loss and beat a young, undefeated and hungry champion who has stopped all his opponents within 7 rounds. Easily top 10 on the list of heavyweight champions.

Welllllll..... if he beats AJ by clinching, mauling, wrestling, fouling, and all the other stuff he's prone to do... he'll enhance his reputation as one of the sneakiest, craftiest HW's in history, and will retire without ever having that epic fight that should define great champions.

[vidgil]

I agree with Tito. If Wlad can come back and win not by wrestling but by BOXING, then we will have to tip our hats to the man.

But I suspect with GREAT certainty that AJ will knock out Wlad.

[Master]

I don't think there's anything wrong with saying Wlad fought like a big sissy!

If Wlad beats AJ, his legacy will be greatly enhanced as he has come back from a loss and beat a young, undefeated and hungry champion who has stopped all his opponents within 7 rounds. Easily top 10 on the list of heavyweight champions.

Welllllll..... if he beats AJ by clinching, mauling, wrestling, fouling, and all the other stuff he's prone to do... he'll enhance his reputation as one of the sneakiest, craftiest HW's in history, and will retire without ever having that epic fight that should define great champions.

No well about it. If he wins then he should be recognised. Beating 6ft 6 inch Olympic and world champ is an accomplishment.