How good was Floyd?

[Master]

I rank them Floyd, Hop, and then Roy. Hop beat the best competition of the three and has some very impressive legacy accomplishments like most middleweight defenses, oldest champ, oldest to unify…etc. For me Floyd edges him due to consistency, undefeated status, and number of weight classes he won titles in.

bernard, floyd, roy for me

Even though Roy beat Hopkins in/nearer their primes?

[TIC]

I rank them Floyd, Hop, and then Roy. Hop beat the best competition of the three and has some very impressive legacy accomplishments like most middleweight defenses, oldest champ, oldest to unify…etc. For me Floyd edges him due to consistency, undefeated status, and number of weight classes he won titles in.

bernard, floyd, roy for me

Even though Roy beat Hopkins in/nearer their primes?

on an all time list, yes. head to head at both their bests like a mythical match up no