Canelo Álvarez v Jermell Charlo September Thirtieth

[TIC]

will you give canelo any credit if he fights david b in his three fight contract with pbc? as for suspense, i was saying before the dmitry fight that it was a really hard fight & most of us here agreed that dmitry was the second best light heavyweight in the world at that time, that fight was nowhere near a foregone conclusion. you see it as a miscalculation, i see it as an extremely difficult challenge

IMO it was both. No doubt it became an extremely difficult challenge. But also a miscalculation, because that hasn't been Canelo's M.O. throughout his career. Most of his fights have been coldly pre-calculated, to give Canelo every possible advantage within the rules... (and at least once outside the rules). Taking on Bivol was uncharacteristic for Canelo. No doubt he was emboldened by previous successes against Rocky Fielding and Kovalev. But Bivol turned out to be much more of a live dog. Wanting to challenge Ilunga Makabu, and wanting to drain Badou Jack 20 pounds below his weight... those are more Canelo's style.

Will I give Canelo credit if he fights Benavidez in his 3-fight contract with PBC? Depends. If it does, which I doubt... it needs to happen soon. So Canelo will have no age excuse when he gets KTFO'ed.

BTW... whatever happened to Canelo's previously used excuse about not wanting to fight fellow Mexicans? I remember him pulling that one out from under his sleeve when David's name first started being mentioned.

Ginger's got a ready-made excuse for everything.

taking on the second best fighter in a division two weights above your last fight is an extremely difficult challenge from the start in my opinion. no miscalculation, just a very big task. can i ask did you see canelo as the favourite going into the floyd & first ggg fights? & who did you have winning the first ggg fight?

I saw Floyd as the favorite. I didn't think Canelo deserved a shot at Floyd, and I was proven right. One of the easiest wins Floyd has had against high profile fighters. I also saw GGG as the favorite in their first fight, although it took long enough (way too long) to make the fight. GGG gave Canelo way too much respect... and still I thought he did enough to win the fight. Unfortunately, GGG didn't get the memo that NO ONE gets decisions against Canelo in Vegas. It has to be a total whitewash (Floyd, Bivol)... and even THEN the judges somehow manage to try and screw it up.

Now tell me this. Why do you think Canelo thought up this new excuse about not fighting Mexicans when first approached about Benavidez, when in the past it wasn't a hindrance? (JCC Jr., Angulo, Josesito, etc)

so you thought canelo was the underdog against floyd, you saw him as the underdog against ggg in the first fight & thought he lost, who canelo then took an immediate rematch against a guy you & i both thought beat him. beforre that he took on austin trout who was seen as the number one guy at fifty four, he fought erislandy who no one has really dominated, he clearly defeated danny jacobs who many felt had beaten ggg & then unified one sixty eight by beating three undefeated champions in callum, billy joe & caleb. he also challenge two light heavyweight beltholders. sure there are cash grabs, every fighters record has them at this level but canelo has taken on difficult challenges. as to canelo & fighting mexicans i can only speculate. in my opinion he wanted david b & jaime munguia to establish themselves further before fighting them. or it could be that he didn't want to take food/ money off their tables by beating them at that time. i'm sure you would agree that both guys have had decent paydays in that time, having suffered a defeat to canelo at that time may have deminished their standing in the sport & put them to the back off the line