The problem with moving someone past Floyd at P4P #1 is that it's not just opponents but Floyd's skill set to boxing insiders is so impressive. He can do everything in boxing and there are hardly any holes in his game. Plus, he's performed at a championship at 130, 135, 140, 147, and 154. It's not like he's fighting bums like maybe RJJ did, the guy has been fighting at the championship level at each weight class he's been to. Considering the fact that Floyd is still just a blown up light welterweight, that's really saying something. It's not like Floyd has been on the top 10 P4P list for a couple years, the guy has been top 10 P4P for more than a decade, he hasn't lost, and he keeps piling up quality win after quality win. I really don't understand these random people claiming someone else is p4p #1. That's Floyd's spot until he retires or loses.

With ALL that being said, JoeCal is the only person that I wouldn't have a problem moving past Floyd on the P4P list.

Manny Pacquiao is great and has great wins but he hasn't fought at enough weights despite being big enough. Plus, at 130, prime for prime, there's no way in hell I could ever see Pacquiao beating Floyd. No way.

I could see JoeCal moving past Floyd because Joe is such a briliant boxer. He just doesn't have enough wins against quality opposition to move past Floyd and hasn't competed at enough weights. But if he decivisely beats B-Hop, then maybe Pavlik/JT, and then another quality guy like Dawson. I personally wouldn't move JoeCal past Floyd but Joe's been so dominant for so long just like Floyd that I wouldn't have a huge problem with it.