No matter who he beats, can calzaghe be the lbs4lbs greatest?

[PRIDE OF BOSTON]

Welcome to the site mate - nice thread.

As somebody said previously, JC could beat a prime Ali and still not be percived p4p1 number 1 in a lot of peoples minds. I also agree with Fenster that p4p is all about who would win if you could theoretically make all fighters the same weight reach etc and going by that I could not see JC as p4p number 1 now or anytime soon. For the record he is one of my top 5 fighters ever!

you cant or dont think there have been 5 better fighters than Joe Calzaghe in the history of boxing ??
you are either on drugs or are currently wearing a restrictive jacket in a padded cell.

Try reading - I said "MY" top 5 fighters and even made another post directly below saying "MY PERSONAL FAVOURITE FIGHTERS"

Johnny Lawrence is by far #1 P4P

1- Johnny(devistating power and speed- They almost needed to "Get him a bodybag, Yeah!" He was beaten by up and comer Danny Larouso due to being on the downslide of his career. Larouso used questionable techniques to win the fight. Many, to this day think that "sweeping the leg" should have ended it. Larouso's trainer, Mr Miyagi, while in the dressing room between bouts "Fixed" his leg...


2- Bobby
3- Tommy
4- Dutch
5- Jimmy


Simple as that... Cobra Kai. Never Die.