Prime Calzaghe vs Prime Jones Jr. who wins?

[ICB]

Put it this way, Calzaghe has never comer close to losing in the longest championship reign in boxing

Joe has also beaten 2 undefeated reigning champs

Jones has only defeated 1 undefeted reigning champ in Toney


We will see the quality of those wins in the furure for Joe, Toney went on to lose a few times and get caugt taking steroids as has Jones

Both Calzaghes victims have bounced back, 1 with a title

I think it is possibly more patriotism that so many people have backed Jones because how any one can say he would beat Joe handily when he has been sparked and beaten a few times and Joe is still throwing the most punches in a fight out of all the current champs and hasnt come close to losing or slowing down even at 36

Im not even going to debate with you on this your previous posts have showed your biased towards British fighters and your Roy Jones Jr hater which is a fact. All i'll say is that you said Calzaghe has never come close to losing then you must of missed his fights with Hopkins/Reid, and also his fight with Salem where he was dropped heavily with a right hand.

[ross]

How is getting floored close to losing?

Split decision wins are also not close to losing, getting a draw is close

Jones lost a few times and sparked a couple as well, he also got caught cheating with steroids, its all old news, no use crying over spilt milk.

No one can say Jones would have beaten Calzaghe because Joe has proven unbeatable so far against some excellent fighters and some that were young undefeated champs.

Whereas Jones has proven time again hes not unbeatable

Joe would be a handfull for anyone in history

[Majesty]

Jones lost a few times and sparked a couple as well, he also got caught cheating with steroids, its all old news, no use crying over spilt milk.

Roy lost and looked vulnerable only after he came back down from heavyweight and losing that muscle and that can truly mess you up for quite a while. I've yet to see Calzaghe take that kind of risk.

And Roy didn't get caught cheating with steroids, did you even follow the story?

It was Ripped Fuel over the counter, and Richard Hall tested positive as well

The Type A test they gave Roy was what came out saying he was over, the second B test said he was clean.

Why do you think his victory stands?

If the type B test was positive then the victory would have been taken away changed to a no contest and Roy would have been suspended.

None of that happened? Why do you think? Because the second test was negative.

So jones didn't get "busted" for steroids.