Prime Calzaghe vs Prime Jones Jr. who wins?

[donnydarkoIRL]

Ray Robinson is the most complete fighter, Roy of the last 20yrs imo.

Ray Robinson was far from a complete fighter.

What would you say Robinson lacked? and if there is a more complete packadge tell me.

I like Willie Pep but he had no power and Ali of the mid 60s at heavyweight was pretty complete.

There were a few important flaws in Robinson.

We could actually start a thread about this and we could rattle out a good debate, but I'm just about to finish work.

If you are here to ask me again tomorrow I'll explain the logic behind my statement.

As for a more complete fighter.
Off the top of my head Pernell Whittaker.