Best Super Middleweight of all time to date?

[ArawakWarria]

Roy beat Toney in this weight class, but he won all of his belts at LightHW. He has spent more than the past decade there, which puts him at top LiteHeavies.

Calzaghe has dominated the division for longer than anyone else in its existence. Seven fights do not outweigh an entire undefeated career.

[mrbig1]

Oh I'm so sick of hearing about Roy Joke JR. He beats a big fat James Toney. Then moves out of a tough Super MW division to a weaker LT HW division. The bum of the month club was born. Far worst than Joe Louis.

[DaxxKahn]

Oh I'm so sick of hearing about Roy Joke JR. He beats a big fat James Toney. Then moves out of a tough Super MW division to a weaker LT HW division. The bum of the month club was born. Far worst than Joe Louis.

Did Roy snatch your Grandmothers purse or something?...Thats the only reason I can think of a comment like that...OR you have no idea what you are talking about

At the time Jones fought Toney James was

A- Not fat
B- One of the P4P elite of the sport
C- One of the most feared punchers in the sport

Get a grip

[eagle]

Oh I'm so sick of hearing about Roy Joke JR. He beats a big fat James Toney. Then moves out of a tough Super MW division to a weaker LT HW division. The bum of the month club was born. Far worst than Joe Louis.

I Think this guy is a british Calzaghe fanboy who has made up an alias, and put up the american flag to throw ppl off. Dickhead.

[wesrman]

Roy Jones was incredible as a SMW.

[mrbig1]

Oh I'm so sick of hearing about Roy Joke JR. He beats a big fat James Toney. Then moves out of a tough Super MW division to a weaker LT HW division. The bum of the month club was born. Far worst than Joe Louis.

I Think this guy is a british Calzaghe fanboy who has made up an alias, and put up the american flag to throw ppl off. Dickhead.

No, I'm red,white,and blue from Louisville,ky. I think Toney had to hit the scales 3 times before making the weight. That takes nothing away from Jones.Roy Jones had great skill,power and speed. He seems to go out of his way not to take on the very best. I think HBO had a great deal to do with it Protecting their super star. You're not going to find Hall,frazier, or Woods on your p4p list. Jones, other than Toney or a green Hopkins had never really been tested. Can he win a hard fight? Can he get off the canvas to win? The worst player in baseball would be in the hall of fame if my daughter was doing the pitching. This is why I can't call Jones a great fighter.