calzaghe haters a question

[leggy]

i think his record speaks for itself?

i think hopkins even tho he is old is fighting really well at the moment so i wouldnt call him shot or past his prime

[El Kabong]

Joe fought Hopkins and Jones at times that favored Joe's chances....it's just the way the chips fell. Both Hopkins and Jones took the fights wanting to win but physically couldn't get it done anymore.

I think Joe is a great fighter, but other than the wins over Lacy, Kessler, and maybe Robin Reid he never tested himself against prime fighters who posed a threat to him. AND old Hopkins and Roy knocked him down in the first round...that makes me question how the prime versions of those fighters would have handled Joe.


People are for the right or wrong reasons ALWAYS question how legitimate an undefeated record is....people STILL give Rocky Marciano crap for his 49-0-0. Consider it an honor that people give Joe crap for his record, he's earned it and in any argument you can at least pride yourself in the fact that he's not Svenn Ottke