Joe Calzaghe P4P #1?

[ICB]

Anybody think JMM beat Pac twice? If he did then Pac aint number 1!!

Yes i think JMM beat Manny Pacquiao twice, but i also think Robin Reid, Bernard Hopkins, beat Joe Calzaghe so that works both ways

You must have JMM number 1 then ?

Yea why not ? if you think a fighter lost a certain fight, you should rank them lower in the P4P rankings, because its your opinion and your list. Forgetting what the record books say.

I think Pernell Whitaker should only have 1 loss on his record, and i think he should be top 10 P4P of all time. And i think Muhammad Ali should have atleast 9 losses on his record and he should be out of the top 10 P4P of all time, thats the beauty of P4P lists mate.

[BIG H]

Yes i think JMM beat Manny Pacquiao twice, but i also think Robin Reid, Bernard Hopkins, beat Joe Calzaghe so that works both ways

You must have JMM number 1 then ?

Yea why not ? if you think a fighter lost a certain fight, you should rank them lower in the P4P rankings, because its your opinion and your list. Forgetting what the record books say.

I think Pernell Whitaker should only have 1 loss on his record, and i think he should be top 10 P4P of all time. And i think Muhammad Ali should have atleast 9 losses on his record and he should be out of the top 10 P4P of all time, thats the beauty of P4P lists mate.

Fair play mate. I agree Sweet P should be to 10 p4p of all time. I'm interested to see which 9 fights you had Ali losing (I guess you had him losing all 3 versus Norton)

[ICB]

You must have JMM number 1 then ?

Yea why not ? if you think a fighter lost a certain fight, you should rank them lower in the P4P rankings, because its your opinion and your list. Forgetting what the record books say.

I think Pernell Whitaker should only have 1 loss on his record, and i think he should be top 10 P4P of all time. And i think Muhammad Ali should have atleast 9 losses on his record and he should be out of the top 10 P4P of all time, thats the beauty of P4P lists mate.

Fair play mate. I agree Sweet P should be to 10 p4p of all time. I'm interested to see which 9 fights you had Ali losing (I guess you had him losing all 3 versus Norton)

I just watched Ken Norton vs Muhammad trilogy again, and i did have him losing all 3 fights. Ken Norton with his crab like style defense, would block Muhammad Ali's jab with his right glove constantly and counter with rising jabs over the top, plus he was putting on effective pressure all night.

It reminded me of Larry Holmes vs Tim Witherspoon, because just like Ken Norton. Tim Witherspoon with his crab like style defense. Would block Larry Holmes jab with his right glove, and counter with rising jabs over the top. And was putting effective pressure on all night, although i had Larry Holmes vs Tim Witherspoon a draw.

I also had Muhammad Ali losing to Jimmy Young, Earnie Shavers, i thought he got a draw with Doug Jones. And technically he should of been DQ in the Henry Cooper fight, because after the knockdown he was given smelling salts, which wern't allowed in the UK at that time i believe.