I'd say that the Margarito win trumps any of Chad's wins, but Chad has a few big wins and Williams really only has that one, plus the loss to Quintana. Then I guess it depends on who you think is the better fighter, if you're just comparing the two.
Let me ask you this.
PW beat Antonio Margarito. He never entered P4P top 10 status.
Antonio Margarito all of a sudden beats Miguel Cotto.
Now PW enters the top 10 ?
It doesn't make sense because PW is entering on behalf of Margarito's win over Cotto.
Not because Paul Williams has followed up on that win, hell no. Being took to school by Carlos Quintana is hardly following up.
It's just stupid IMO.
Doesn't matter about the rematch. Quintana is only a contender anyway.
My point is beating Antonio Margarito last year and not following it up shouldn't make you P4P worthy IMO (And everyone else almost agrees on this thread).
Antonio Margarito has never been P4P worthy only untill after he beat Cotto recently.
Antonio Margarito was probably just about top 20 P4P when Paul Williams beat him if that. What Antonio Margarito has done recently should not give Paul Williams a free pass in the top 10 P4P.
Like Leftylee just said Vic Darchinyan just dominated a top 6 P4P fighter, so why isn't he in the top 10 ? or why isn't Chad Dawson in the top 10 ? he has solid wins over Antonio Tarver, Glen Johnson, Eric Harding, Tomasz Adamek.
I'd like to know what Paul Williams has done to deserve to be rated above. Chad Dawson or Vic Darchinyan.
Last edited by ICB; 11-19-2008 at 05:57 PM.
There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)
Bookmarks