Top 100 All-Time Greats: Post your list here...

[Fenster]

Do you mean Roy ducked Michalczewski? I don't think Roy ducked Calzaghe.

Now Daxx, don't get annoyed, all your points are perfectly reasonable BUT

Comparing their best wins - you have marked down Roy's win over Hopkins because he was "new to the game" ... yet you give Hopkins extra credit for being the first man to beat Johnson. This is a bit inconsistent.

McCallum was past his best. But then surely it's only fair to mention Oscar was fighting way above his natural weightclass.. this goes for Tito, Wright and Pavlik too.

Apart from that - Good point about Hopkins never being stopped or dominated. I don't agree he should rate above Roy, but there's no right or wrong with these lists just opinion - as you said.