Who is the P4P no1 today?

[killersheep]

PAC cannot even be considered p4p until he stops ducking Mighty Mike

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UJGxQOwgZ2c

here you can clearly see Mighty dominating his opponent in a much great fashion than PAC over ODLH.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NwaKUgKvMtE

[Bomp]

I picked JMM, but it's real close. I thought he won the Pac rematch, couple that with his last two fights trumping Pac's (revisionist or not, Diaz on the weekend was a much livelier opponent than Oscar) and I think JMM shades it. Pac beats Hatton and he's back on top.

[JazMerkin]

PAC cannot even be considered p4p until he stops ducking Mighty Mike

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UJGxQOwgZ2c

here you can clearly see Mighty dominating his opponent in a much great fashion than PAC over ODLH.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NwaKUgKvMtE

I'm with you killer, I can have nothing to do with any P4P list that does not include this Greek God.

[ElTerribleMorales]

Beating a babyboy who never won a fight against active elite fighters doesn't mean you're the best in the world.

Beating David who struggled against Silverio Ortiz who was robbed in that fight in one of the worst robberies ever. Diaz also struggled vs. Montana in his previous fight and won a MD fight where Montana was able to tag him and push him around.

I don't even have to mention the ODLH thing that was just crazy to think ODLH could perform well at 147.

JMM has become the lineal champ not some title holder.
He beat the lineal champ in Joel and he beat the #2 rated guy by The Ring becoming the man in the div.

don't forget to mention that Diaz struggled against a shot Morales, and that Morales was basically robbed, the same shot Morales that Pacquiao stopped in 3 the fight right before, and how is Hatton on the list but not Cotto? seeing how Cotto is actually on the p4p list and Hatton is not

[XaduBoxer]

At this point, I still consider PAC as the current no. 1 P4P boxer. Starting from PAC-JMM rematch fight, PAC's win over JMM, David Diaz and Hoya is far greater achievement than JMM's win over Casa and Juan Diaz... So JMM didn't overtake PAC just yet...
.

You are soo biased that you have not a valid opinion to your name. If Pac wasn't fighting, you wouldn't even watch boxing. Why the fuck would anyone care what you said??

Like me, Ring Magazine is soo biased since they still have PAC as P4P no. 1 as of March 1, 2009 even dumping their very own Golden Boy Promotions boxer, Juan Manuel Marquez to no. 2 spot only... Ring Mag is sooooo biased... From now on, I'll used their magazine pages as toilet paper for my dog...

[boozeboxer]

At this point, I still consider PAC as the current no. 1 P4P boxer. Starting from PAC-JMM rematch fight, PAC's win over JMM, David Diaz and Hoya is far greater achievement than JMM's win over Casa and Juan Diaz... So JMM didn't overtake PAC just yet...
.

You are soo biased that you have not a valid opinion to your name. If Pac wasn't fighting, you wouldn't even watch boxing. Why the fuck would anyone care what you said??

Like me, Ring Magazine is soo biased since they still have PAC as P4P no. 1 as of March 1, 2009 even dumping their very own Golden Boy Promotions boxer, Juan Manuel Marquez to no. 2 spot only... Ring Mag is sooooo biased... From now on, I'll used their magazine pages as toilet paper for my dog...

You would wipe your dog's ass.

[iwng100]

Just to do my part in debasing the legitimacy of this poll, I voted Hatton.

If I had to choose between Pac and JMM though, I would pick Pac.

This is your real thought or just the prediction for the 2nd may ?

[CFH]

Just to do my part in debasing the legitimacy of this poll, I voted Hatton.

If I had to choose between Pac and JMM though, I would pick Pac.

This is your real thought or just the prediction for the 2nd may ?

Nah, I'm just being a jackass. Thus the debasing comment. I really hope Hatton beats the shit out of Pacquiao though.

[XaduBoxer]

You are soo biased that you have not a valid opinion to your name. If Pac wasn't fighting, you wouldn't even watch boxing. Why the fuck would anyone care what you said??

Like me, Ring Magazine is soo biased since they still have PAC as P4P no. 1 as of March 1, 2009 even dumping their very own Golden Boy Promotions boxer, Juan Manuel Marquez to no. 2 spot only... Ring Mag is sooooo biased... From now on, I'll used their magazine pages as toilet paper for my dog...

You would wipe your dog's ass.

Nope... I got a very smart dog that's capable of wiping his own ass... The dog's name is ... you guess it right... "Pacman"...
.

[Majesty]

Shane beating Margarito was more shocking

[rjj tszyu]

This is real close 24 - 24 pac and Marquez. I must admit I thought there might have been a bit more Hopkins loving going on after he demolished Pavlik.

[rjj tszyu]

Oh yeah Mick. Forgot about Valuev completely when making this list! Might restart it just to add him

[kingfrnk]

its JMM. sure he lost to pac but in a close decision but most felt JMM won. the both moved up to lightweight pac fought David Diaz who was stopped before by Holt and was just a paper champ. JMM fought the RING champ at lightweight and was the 1st to stop him. Pac went up in weight to fight Oscar at 147 which is a weight Oscar hasnt fought at in years and had already shown he was on the decline. JMM fought Juan Diaz who was one of the top lightweights today and in his prime and in his division. that makes JMM p4p 1 to me.

[HattonTheHammer]

This is real close 24 - 24 pac and Marquez. I must admit I thought there might have been a bit more Hopkins loving going on after he demolished Pavlik.

hops number 3 and for a guy approaching 44 thats pretty much unbelievable

[Gandalf]

its JMM. sure he lost to pac but in a close decision but most felt JMM won. the both moved up to lightweight pac fought David Diaz who was stopped before by Holt and was just a paper champ. JMM fought the RING champ at lightweight and was the 1st to stop him. Pac went up in weight to fight Oscar at 147 which is a weight Oscar hasnt fought at in years and had already shown he was on the decline. JMM fought Juan Diaz who was one of the top lightweights today and in his prime and in his division. that makes JMM p4p 1 to me.

Good post. I can agree with that.