Is Manny Pacquiao Bad For Boxing?

[ICB]

cuz thats what all the greats in history have done

Who? Who are these greats? Armstrong?, Jones? please inform us...

Who else has gone from 106lbs to fight at 142lbs?

Who else has titles in 5 weight classes at the moment and as many lineial titles? Who has claimed as many ring titles?

even if they have done one of the above who else has done all of the above?

The man has done his job and well he has nothing to prove by fighting under everyone elses terms

Oscar moved up from superfeather to middleweight and won world titles in each divison. Pac hasnt, not to mention Oscar wasnt always fighting guys on their way out.

Any guy who has moved up in weight has moved into their opponents division and thats why they get props. How can anyone get props if they are beating up on a weight drained corpse. If Manny wants to do it at all he should do it properly.

Agreed.


Super Featherweight

Troy Dorsey
Jeff Mayweather
Jimmi Bredhal
Giorgio Campanella


Lightweight

Jorge Paez
John John Molina
Rafael Ruelas
Genaro Hernandez
Jesse James Leija


Jr Welterweight

Julio Cesar Chavez
Miguel Angel Gonzalez


Welterweight

Pernell Whitaker
David Kamau
Hector Camacho
Wilfredo Rivera
Julio Cesar Chavez 2
Ike Quartey
Oba Carr
Felix Trinidad
Shane Mosley
Arturo Gatti
Manny Pacquiao
Steve Forbes

Light Middleweight

Javier Castillejo
Fernando Vargas
Yori Boy Campas
Shane Mosley 2
Ricardo Mayorga
Floyd Mayweather Jr

Middleweight

Felix Sturm
Bernard Hopkins

What a resume.

[DaxxKahn]

Who? Who are these greats? Armstrong?, Jones? please inform us...

Who else has gone from 106lbs to fight at 142lbs?

Who else has titles in 5 weight classes at the moment and as many lineial titles? Who has claimed as many ring titles?

even if they have done one of the above who else has done all of the above?

The man has done his job and well he has nothing to prove by fighting under everyone elses terms

Oscar moved up from superfeather to middleweight and won world titles in each divison. Pac hasnt, not to mention Oscar wasnt always fighting guys on their way out.

Any guy who has moved up in weight has moved into their opponents division and thats why they get props. How can anyone get props if they are beating up on a weight drained corpse. If Manny wants to do it at all he should do it properly.

Agreed.


Super Featherweight

Troy Dorsey
Jeff Mayweather
Jimmi Bredhal
Giorgio Campanella


Lightweight

Jorge Paez
John John Molina
Rafael Ruelas
Genaro Hernandez
Jesse James Leija


Jr Welterweight

Julio Cesar Chavez
Miguel Angel Gonzalez


Welterweight

Pernell Whitaker
David Kamau
Hector Camacho
Wilfredo Rivera
Julio Cesar Chavez 2
Ike Quartey
Oba Carr
Felix Trinidad
Shane Mosley
Arturo Gatti
Manny Pacquiao
Steve Forbes

Light Middleweight

Javier Castillejo
Fernando Vargas
Yori Boy Campas
Shane Mosley 2
Ricardo Mayorga
Floyd Mayweather Jr

Middleweight

Felix Sturm
Bernard Hopkins

What a resume.

DLH has perhaps the best resume in boxing over the last 40-50 years just because a fighter does not have his resume does not detract from his skillset if that was the case

PBF, B-Hop, RJJ, Lennox Lewis, Tyson, Holyfield, Cotto, Mosley, Wright, Hatton, Williams, etc have all accomplished nothing in their careers