Why do you hate Amir Khan poll

[The Congressman]

Bilbo. I agree that PWill should be higher than Donaire. Dawson, Abraham, Pavlik, and Kessler shouldn't be in to 10 though. Obviously you don't see something special about Donaire that's why you see him as overrated fighter. Darchinyan is not even in his level.

[Kev]

Bilbo. I agree that PWill should be higher than Donaire. Dawson, Abraham, Pavlik, and Kessler shouldn't be in to 10 though. Obviously you don't see something special about Donaire that's why you see him as overrated fighter. Darchinyan is not even in his level.

It's not that I don't see anything special, its just he's not done anything to warrant a p4p spot.

I think Andre Ward, Andre Dirrell, Yuriorkis Gamboa, Kell Brook all look like potential elite fighters but they havn't proven themselves yet, although Andre Ward imo has already beaten better opposition than Donaire.

He may turn out to be a great great fighter, but he should have to earn his spot in the top 10.

Dawson has done so much more in his career, as has Paul Williams, Arthur Abraham and Kessler.

[OumaFan]

Bilbo. I agree that PWill should be higher than Donaire. Dawson, Abraham, Pavlik, and Kessler shouldn't be in to 10 though. Obviously you don't see something special about Donaire that's why you see him as overrated fighter. Darchinyan is not even in his level.

It's not that I don't see anything special, its just he's not done anything to warrant a p4p spot.

I think Andre Ward, Andre Dirrell, Yuriorkis Gamboa, Kell Brook all look like potential elite fighters but they havn't proven themselves yet, although Andre Ward imo has already beaten better opposition than Donaire.

He may turn out to be a great great fighter, but he should have to earn his spot in the top 10.

Dawson has done so much more in his career, as has Paul Williams, Arthur Abraham and Kessler.

I tried to only use that smilie on General Bulldog's posts but meh I just couldn't do it.

[generalbulldog]

The consensus out there is that Donaire is not a top 10 p4p fighter. Minus the Darchinyan victory and what does his resume look like? It's not very impressive. And then you have this guy ranked above Paul Williams who's willing to fight anyone in 3 weight classes with a much superior resume.

It's hard to defend Donaire as being a top 10 p4p fighter.