does the winner of the SMW super six have a better resume than Calzaghe??

[ryanman]

and how is that?

NONSENSE - you're speaking out of your rear end there pal.

Jermain Taylor already has a better resume than Calzaghe

Apart from 2 close some would say unfair wins over Hopkins what has taylor ever done.

He has look great in parts of fights but has never put it together for a full fight.

Maybe I should of made myself a little more clearer. I was talking about fighters faced. Taylor in 32 fights has already faced better fighters than Calzaghe did in 46. Taylor's opposition of Bernard Hopkins (x2), Winky Wright, Kassim Ouma, Cory Spinks, Carl Froch, Kelly Pavlik (x 2) and William Joppy is clearly better than Calzaghe's of Mikkel kessler, Bernard Hopkins, Jeff Lacy, Robin Reid, Sakio Bika and Chris Eubanks

Yea maybe the list of names you mention on Taylor's resume are more impressive than Calzaghe's list, but considering of those names he lost to Froch, and Pavlik x 2, it doesn't really stack up. Surely you have to beat the guys on your resume to make it an impressive resume. If not its probably some journeyman with the best resume, having fought a load of big names that were on their way up.
Anyway, should Taylor go unbeaten throughout the comp, he would probably have a better resume. But definately not now.

[Fenster]

VD's right, everyone remembers how terrifying Ouma and Spinks were at middleweight. Those were great wins.

[Violent Demise]

VD's right, everyone remembers how terrifying Ouma and Spinks were at middleweight. Those were great wins.

And they never accomplished the great achievement of reaching the Contender final like the great Peter Manfredo

[Fenster]

VD's right, everyone remembers how terrifying Ouma and Spinks were at middleweight. Those were great wins.

And they never accomplished the great achievement of reaching the Contender final like the great Peter Manfredo

Ouma lost to a guy that didn't even make the Contender final