Hopkins v Toney

[Fenster]

Toney would knock his ugly snaggletooth ass into outer space.

[ICB]

I think James Toney was better at Super Middleweight, but he still had some incredible performances at Middleweight vs Nunn, McCallum. But at Super Middleweight his performances vs Barkley, DeWitt, Williams, Littles, are unbelievable.

He seemed to be mentally and physically at his peak at Super Middleweight, so im going with B-Hop at Middleweight. And James Toney at Super Middleweight, and i do think James Toney is the better fighter, and is more exciting to watch aswell.

[HattonTheHammer]

I think James Toney was better at Super Middleweight, but he still had some incredible performances at Middleweight vs Nunn, McCallum. But at Super Middleweight his performances vs Barkley, DeWitt, Williams Littles.

He seemed to be at his peak at Super Middleweight, so im going with B-Hop at Middleweight. And James Toney at Super Middleweight, i do think James Toney is the better fighter, and is more exciting to watch fight aswell.

My heart wants to say a 160 pound toney beats a prime hopkins

head says hopkins unanimous decision

[Nameless]

Toney would knock his ugly snaggletooth ass into outer space.

I wish I would have writtenthat myself.

[Dark Lord Al]

hopkins wins at middle , toney wins at SM .

[Kirkland Laing]

A nonstop brawl with both of them fouling the shit out of each other. Headbutts, elbows, you name it. It goes to the cards and Toney gets the decision.

[Master]

Hopkins was more consistent at Middleweight, Toney had some shockers at that weight. Super middle he was good but against fighters which suited him better, so still say B Hop. At light heavy would be interesting and at Cruiser and heavy, Toney all the way.

[Pugilistic]

Thats a seriously tough fight to pick.

Either guy could win.

[El Kabong]

No matter when it happens I just think it's an ugly ass fight. James Toney and Bernard Hopkins their styles don't match. Toney allows guys on the inside and Hopkins likes to gore his opponents with his head down and act like some sissy ass Italian soccer player whenever he's close to being fouled. Both guys would be gunning for the right cross/overhand right. Hopkins would try to utilize the jab and maybe it's effective, maybe not but everything else Toney rolls with and counters.

I think a fight vs Eubank or Benn or even Steve Collins would have been a lot better looking.