I think James Toney was better at Super Middleweight, but he still had some incredible performances at Middleweight vs Nunn, McCallum. But at Super Middleweight his performances vs Barkley, DeWitt, Williams, Littles, are unbelievable.

He seemed to be mentally and physically at his peak at Super Middleweight, so im going with B-Hop at Middleweight. And James Toney at Super Middleweight, and i do think James Toney is the better fighter, and is more exciting to watch aswell.