Why would Marquez be a more viable opponent than Mosley for Manny?

[Rantcatrat]

Do you think Marquez vs. Pacquiao at 147 would be more interesting?

Definitely. Marquez doesn't have to weigh in at 147. He can weigh in at around 138lb ish. Pacquiao will weigh in at around 147lbs. When they re-hydrate, Pacquiao would probably only be around 150lbs and Marquez would be around 145-147lbs. I don't think it will make a tonne of difference.

It's not his size and strength that are dangerous to Pacquiao. It's his all round ability. It would be much more exciting than Pacquiao - Mosley.

I'm just not sure. I'm not convinced Marquez is as effective above 135 and I'm not convinced Mosley isn't completely passed it at this point in his career. That is why I think a Bradley fight gives Pacquiao the most credibility.

If you were Marquez and you wanted the fight with Pacquiao so badly, and Pacquiao is now fighting at 147 and 150 pounds, what would you do put yourself in the best possible position to get the fight? I would challenge a big name at 140 or 147 and then give Pacquiao no excuses. What does Marquez do? He fights Kastidis at 135. It makes me wonder how comfortable Marquez really is above 135. If I were him, I'd be championing to fight the winner of the Bradley/Alexander or Maidana/Khan fight or Shane Mosley himself.

[fan johnny]

Do you think Marquez vs. Pacquiao at 147 would be more interesting?

Definitely. Marquez doesn't have to weigh in at 147. He can weigh in at around 138lb ish. Pacquiao will weigh in at around 147lbs. When they re-hydrate, Pacquiao would probably only be around 150lbs and Marquez would be around 145-147lbs. I don't think it will make a tonne of difference.

It's not his size and strength that are dangerous to Pacquiao. It's his all round ability. It would be much more exciting than Pacquiao - Mosley.

I'm just not sure. I'm not convinced Marquez is as effective above 135 and I'm not convinced Mosley isn't completely passed it at this point in his career. That is why I think a Bradley fight gives Pacquiao the most credibility.

If you were Marquez and you wanted the fight with Pacquiao so badly, and Pacquiao is now fighting at 147 and 150 pounds, what would you do put yourself in the best possible position to get the fight? I would challenge a big name at 140 or 147 and then give Pacquiao no excuses. What does Marquez do? He fights Kastidis at 135. It makes me wonder how comfortable Marquez really is above 135. If I were him, I'd be championing to fight the winner of the Bradley/Alexander or Maidana/Khan fight or Shane Mosley himself.

Is it your logic or are you just thinking superficial here? I don't get it. How does it make any difference what weight class they set the fight at? They will both step into the ring at their fighting weight. Their weight will be pretty close to the weight they fought at as super featherweights. The only difference I see is they don't have to dehydrate to make weight. Wouldn't it be more comfortable for both fighters to come in at their natural fighting weight than to have to dehydrate to make a lower weight?