Calzaghe's win over B-Hop looks better all the time.......

[roberto duran legend]

Yeah i agree , the super six has had its problems but at least we can see the best fighting the best its a great concept .

[roberto duran legend]

Kirkland Laing is not in the same league .

[generalbulldog]

Speaking of Kirkland, he hasn't been around since he got into an argument with Lyle here. That fucker was funny.

[marbleheadmaui]

Kirkland Laing is not in the same league .

Again I am asking, what is your point? Because saying head to head results, even among fighters in the same league, determines some sort of ranking just doesn't wash in boxing. Styles make fights.

Marciano beat Ezzard twice, anyone rank Marciano higher?

[roberto duran legend]

My point is that Joe Calzaghe beat everyone he fought , ok some were mediocre , some good and some great , but he did win them all , not saying he is a legend , and i understand there is a much deeper pool of talent now than say 2 or 3 years ago , i would still take Calzaghe to beat ward IMO , he struggled against lesser opposition but always had his A game against the best he fought .

[roberto duran legend]

What do u class as a cheap win a win is a win , would it be a cheap win if Hopkins won ?? i dont think so .

[marbleheadmaui]

My point is that Joe Calzaghe beat everyone he fought , ok some were mediocre , some good and some great , but he did win them all , not saying he is a legend , and i understand there is a much deeper pool of talent now than say 2 or 3 years ago , i would still take Calzaghe to beat ward IMO , he struggled against lesser opposition but always had his A game against the best he fought .

IMO beating everyone you fought doesn't mean a great deal. The quality of the competition is almost everything.

Otherwise one has to say Swen Ottke was the equal of Calzaghe