Just to antagonise the haters.

[mrbig1]

Victories over Hopkins,Kessler,and Lacy speaks for itself. If Pacman is defeated I see no reason why Calzaghe shouldn't be #1 P4P.

[GAME]

I already have Joe higher in the p4p rankings , Hes been beating unbeaten champions . Says it all

[Dark Lord Al]

I already have Joe higher in the p4p rankings , Hes been beating unbeaten champions . Says it all

2 in 21 , the rest was predictable garbage.

[Jimanuel Boogustus]

If your all gonna react like this then the question should be, as of this moment, who really deserves the No.2 spot.

Because either way you look at it. If Pac looses clearly, or gets stopped then he looses his P4P No.1 rating pretty much automatically.

[Dizaster]

I know P4P are often hotly debated and not everyone will always agree on something.. But a question i've always thought, is who Calzaghe would have to beat to be crowned P4P number 1 and a majority of people accept it as the right decision.
I mean, there could be people out there right now that could have Calzaghe as their number 1. But for the general public to accept him as number one, and assuming he wasn't going to retire soon, who would he have to beat? How many more fights would he need to take? And do you think that it's even possible for Calzaghe to be put at number 1 before he retires at a realistic age?

[kingfrnk]

Pac stays P4P number 1 regardless of how he looks against Oscar. A shot, faded Roy Jones does nothing for my liking to enhance Slappy's resume.

agree. oscar and jones are not in the p4p rankings. even though they are both great fighters that doesnt mean if manny loses he will lose the #1 spot. and if joe beats jones that doesnt mean hes gonna get the # 1 spot.

[Rantcatrat]

As we all know Calzaghe is fighting Roy Jones in a couple weeks and then we have Pacquaio against Oscar.

Now presuming Calzaghe gets the win over Jones the Ring magazine will most likely rate him as number 2 in the world behind Manny.

Now if Manny gets knocked out or loses decisively to Oscar then I guess we'll have a new p4p number 1 in the sport.

No fighter could get KO'd and remain the number 1 p4p imo even if he was moving up in weight, so he'd probably have to drop down a spot, but Oscar is hardly going to magically leap to number 1 for beating a smaller man considering he's not even in the top 10 at all at present.


So it seems a real possibility that if Joe beats Jones impressively and Oscar decisively beats Manny that Joe Calzaghe will be rated p4p the number 1 fighter in the world.

I can't wait to see the threads that would get started if that happens, and Calzaghe is officially acknowledged as the Ring p4p Champ

Correct me if I'm wrong, but isn't Calzaghe retiring after the Jones fight?

To continue in the theme of antagonizing the haters, the latest from Joe: Joe Calzaghe blast Yanks, Gives verdict on Ricky Hatton, David Haye, Roy Jones Jr and Himself.

[GAME]

I already have Joe higher in the p4p rankings , Hes been beating unbeaten champions . Says it all

2 in 21 , the rest was predictable garbage.

Not really cuz he has been fighting in world class for a long time. You could say the same about Pac. Difference is Joe is still unbeaten .