Skip to content
Boxing News
  • Home
  • Boxing Forum
  • Boxing Videos
  • Contact
Boxing News
Boxing Articles

Boxing Perspective: James Toney TKO 9 Evander Holyfield

ByJames Slater 01/08/2006

Holyfield Fight Still Best Performance At Heavyweight For “Light Out”

James Toney should’nt really be fighting as a heavyweight. This opinion is held by more than a few, both fans and experts. But he is doing so, and until someone comes along and beats him – he is currently 3-0-1, with one no-contest at the weight – James has to be respected as a contender at heavyweight. His next fight, against the huge punching Samuel Peter, just might be the fight where James does lose. But who knows? With his slick skills, “Lights Out” has the ability to outbox many of todays big guys.

To be honest, James has really only looked totally impressive as a heavyweight on one occasion. But I have to admit, that after the way he dismantled his opponent in this very fight, I felt he had certainly made the correct choice in moving up to compete at such a poundage.

However, after this excellent show James went on to gain more weight, and looked sluggish as a result. Still, the display that impressed many is one deserving of respect. The fight in question is James match-up with the legendary Evander Holyfield. I recount the action from this memorable contest in the following text.

The bout was held at The Mandalay Bay in Las Vegas on October the 4th and its tagline was “War On October 4”.

The first round was lively and Holyfield performed like anything but a man of forty years of age. He looked quite sharp and his physique was as magnificent as ever. Evander threw some good digging hooks but Toney’s defence was right on the ball. Still, it was round one to “The Real Deal”. He even put in a few seconds of overtime, throwing a couple after the bell, bringing a retaliation from Toney and a roar from the crowd.

James stood his ground in round two and backed Evander up. His jab was accurate and he wore the usual smug look of complete self assurance. Again they fought at the bell and both men glared at one another.

At the start of the third it looked as though Toney might be in a bit of trouble as he was cracked by a good right hand, but we were soon given the proof we needed as to whether or not “Lights Out” could take a top heavyweights shot.

He rolled away, nullifying any chance of further blows landing and continued with his game plan of going to Evanders body. He got even more cocky near the rounds end and spoke to someone at ringside. Gaining the psychological advantage was never an option James strayed away from and signals such as this must have registered with Holyfield. He wasnt used to such arrogance being shown from the other man in the ring with him, let alone when that man was a former middleweight. James was starting to gain the upper hand already.

Evander was badly hurt for the first time in round four when a Toney right whipped into his head as he was backed up onto the ropes. Toney followed up with a classy combination and the possibility of a KO win arose. Evander came back though, once again living up to the second of his apt nicknames, “Warrior”, and had some success on the other side of the ring as it was James turn to feel his back to the ropes.

It was a good burst from Holyfield and because of it you could make a case for scoring the round even. Toney was definitely the sharper of the two now though. A lot of young fighters really could learn a lot from watching some of Toney’s talented moves and by round five he looked as though he was enjoying himself.

Holyfield was tired now and he looked stiff and slow, throwing only the odd punch that landed. Toney was too quick to let him get the second shot home and he was starting to pull ahead, hurting Evander while taking him to school.

It was clear Toney had retained all his exquisite skills in boxing’s ultimate weight division. By round seven it was a little sad to watch as Evander was being beaten up. His chin was as dependable as ever but he had’nt won a round for an alarming period and his only chance seemed to be him being extremely lucky with James suddenly getting tired.

There were no signs of this and the pain continued for Evander in round eight. James was putting on a master class! Never did I think he would handle Holyfield this easily.

In the ninth Toney closed the show. He had landed a good number of right hands to the head along with some thudding body shots and suddenly all this seemed to catch up with Evander as he crumpled to the floor after a series of left hooks. He beat the count but his corner man, Don Turner, had seen enough and threw in the towel.

Toney had kept his promise, becoming only the second man to stop the legend that is Evander Holyfield. What a statement he had made in doing so. He would now have to be respected by every single heavyweight in the world.

Including Samuel Peter!

Post navigation

Previous Previous
Who Will WBO Boxing Champ Margarito Fight Next?
NextContinue
Boxing Info: Team Soliman Takes DiBella To Task

Boxing Site Team

Owner/Webmaster:
Saddo 📧

Site Photographer:
Jane Warburton 📷
Site Writers:
(Click name to view all that writer’s work)
  • Curtis McCormick
  • Nick Chamberlain
  • Jose Espinoza
  • Robert Brizel
  • Richard Eberline
  • Danny Wilson
  • Bruce Dingo
  • Alejandro Tostado
  • Ricky Jones
  • Wellington Amadulu


RSS Feed

RSS Boxing Forum

  • Dave Allen to return to ring five weeks after Filip Hrgovic loss 23/05/2026
    Allen revealed that he intends to fight four more times as he gears up for one last roll of the dice. The rebuilding process will get underway on June 20 in Rotherham with a four to six-rounder, five weeks removed from his last outing. “June 20th at Rotherham Magna, I will be back in the ring,” Allen posted on Instagram. "I physically cannot sit and wai […]
  • David “the bodysnatcher” whitmire (tic’s prospect watch) 21/05/2026
    if you haven’t been paying attention yet, keep an eye on david “the bodysnatcher” whitmire, one of those young prospects quietly putting it all together. kid’s just 21, sitting at 12-0 with 8 kos, and he’s been in the game longer than you’d think. started boxing at 12 under andrew council, the former world title challenger, and from early on it was clear he […]
  • Bakary Samake and Ermal Hadribeaj Finally Meet in Oberhausen After Paris Collapse 21/05/2026
    Originally published at: Bakary Samake and Ermal Hadribeaj Finally Meet in Oberhausen After Paris Collapse Bakary Samake and Ermal Hadribeaj finally meet in Oberhausen after their original Paris bout collapsed, headlining an Arena Box card packed with WBC regional title fights. 5 posts - 2 participants Read full topic […]
  • Amari Jones vs Vincenzo Gualtieri Preview: Golden Boy Brings Big Test To San Jose 20/05/2026
    Originally published at: Amari Jones vs Vincenzo Gualtieri Preview: Golden Boy Brings Big Test To San Jose Amari Jones faces former world champion Vincenzo Gualtieri in a 12-round IBF middleweight eliminator in San Jose on May 22, headlining a Golden Boy Promotions card featuring Robin Sirwan Safar, John Ramirez and Darius Fulghum live on DAZN. 4 posts - 2 p […]
  • Rolando Dy Crushes Paulie Malignaggi In Two Rounds To Retain Bare Knuckle Title 17/05/2026
    Originally published at: Rolando Dy Crushes Paulie Malignaggi In Two Rounds To Retain Bare Knuckle Title Former two-weight world boxing champion Paulie Malignaggi’s bare knuckle comeback ended in brutal fashion as Rolando Dy stopped him in the second round to retain the BKB Super Welterweight title in Manchester. Malignaggi received a warm reception on the w […]
  • Paddy Donovan Faces Awkward Test Against Karen Chukhadzhian In Germany 14/05/2026
    Originally published at: Paddy Donovan Faces Awkward Test Against Karen Chukhadzhian In Germany Paddy Donovan and Karen Chukhadzhian both made weight at 146.5lbs ahead of their welterweight showdown in Mannheim, Germany, with several unbeaten prospects and heavyweight clashes also featured on the card. 16 posts - 4 participants Read full topic […]
  • Carlos utria (tic’s prospect watch) 14/05/2026
    carlos utria wasn’t even on most people’s radar coming into 2025, now he’s one of the hottest young names at 140. the 22-year-old out of soplaviento, colombia ripped through the wbc grand prix tournament with five wins, finishing the year 14-0 with 11 kos. he beat three unbeaten fighters along the way, stopped elianel guerrero and ntethelelo nkosi, then clos […]
  • Loma making a comeback? 13/05/2026
    Loma is coming out of retirement and making a comeback. The rumours are that his Top Rank contract expires and he is free to return. This leaves him available to face Geovonta Davis or Shakur Stevenson in a huge super fight. 5 posts - 4 participants Read full topic […]
  • So where’s all the old school Saddo members at..? 10/05/2026
    Not been on here in years personally Good to see the sites still up and running Any of the old crew still active? What happened to Curtis ? Fuck me Frank Maloney was pre pre op last time I came on here. Hearn wasn’t even in the game and I seem to remember a female member who knew Kell Brook claimed she got banged in a skip Memphis/Missy/Lyle/Cut me Mick stil […]
  • Max mcintyre (tic’s prospect watch) 07/05/2026
    21 year-old aussie prospect max mcintyre is one to keep an eye on 10-0 (9 kos), youngest queensland champ ever. he won the ibf youth title in just his 7th fight and he’s moving fast. turned pro in 2023 and is already fighting on big cards alongside guys like jai opetaia, and he’s not padding his record either. nicknamed “money,” he’s got that flashy, showman […]
  • On This Day: Corrales vs Castillo I – The Greatest 10th Round Ever (2005) 07/05/2026
    Originally published at: On This Day: Corrales vs Castillo I – The Greatest 10th Round Ever (2005) On May 7, 2005, Diego Corrales and José Luis Castillo delivered one of the greatest fights in boxing history, a brutal war capped by a legendary tenth round that still defines the sport. 5 posts - 5 participants Read full topic […]
  • Abdullah mason v joe cordina july 4th 05/05/2026
    3 posts - 3 participants Read full topic […]
  • Tyson fury 1 or junto nakantani? 04/05/2026
    i questioned making this topic as they are both excellent wins but thought it might create some debate so what is the better win? oleksandr usyk’s first victory over tyson fury or naoya inoue’s victory over junto nakatani? i’ll create a poll as well incase anyone just wants to vote Tyson Fury Junto Nakatani Click to view the poll. 4 posts - 3 participants Re […]
  • Nikita Tszyu vs Oscar Diaz Preview: Unbeaten Clash Headlines Newcastle Card 03/05/2026
    Originally published at: Nikita Tszyu vs Oscar Diaz Preview: Unbeaten Clash Headlines Newcastle Card Nikita Tszyu faces unbeaten Oscar Diaz in a 10-round super welterweight main event in Newcastle on May 6, headlining a stacked No Limit Boxing card featuring multiple unbeaten clashes. 10 posts - 2 participants Read full topic […]
  • Canelo Alvarez v Christian Mbilli 01/05/2026
    Canelo Alvarez and Christian Mbilli have reportedly signed a deal to face each other in September. According to Ring Magazine, the pair will headline a ‘Mexico vs the World’ event in Riyadh, Saudi Arabia. While the report did not explicitly mention a date, it is understood that the bout is being lined up for September 12, to commemorate Mexican Independence […]

© 2026 Boxing News

  • Home
  • Boxing Forum
  • Boxing Videos
  • Contact