Quote Originally Posted by Fenster View Post
I personally enjoy watching Floyd too. I think he's a great fighter.

However, if you want to judge him on paper with Pacquiao, unless you can argue that a knockout, knockdown or savage beatings aren't as impressive, to the majority of fans, as controlled calculated points victories, then you have to accept Pacquiao is the superior fighter based on common opponents.

I'm not saying Manny is a better fighter. I'm merely pointing out the collateral form says he's the better fighter. Fact.

I think i addressed my thoughts on their common opponents. I think Floyd fought a better version of every fighter they each faced EXCEPT Marquez. So your point is mute IMO. I don't think Pac is a superior fighter in ANY way except maybe his style is more crowd pleasing. I actually think if you want to make a case for Pac's resume showing he is the better fighter...you could maybe make a case pointing out his performances in the lower weight classes against the likes of Morales and Barrera...not his performances with opponents he shares with Floyd.