Evander wins. An ATG fighter, best cruiserweight ever beats a flash in the pan with athleticism every time. Regardless of how anyone wants to qualify or excuse the loss, Haye suffered a stoppage defeat against an over the hill opponent. Evander completely cleaned out cruiser and ruined careers.

As for Evander being featherfisted, have to completely disagree with you on that one. Evander was the first to drop Riddick Bowe and Ray Mercer, obliterated Moorer when he was healthy and scored an impressive knockout of Tyson. Evander wasn't a puncher on the level of Shavers, Foreman, Tyson or Lewis but he was by no means as soft a puncher as say Chris Byrd or Maurice Harris.