Boxing Forums



User Tag List

Thanks Thanks:  0
Likes Likes:  0
Dislikes Dislikes:  0
Results 1 to 15 of 27

Thread: ? D`La Hoya vs Cotto ?...........

Share/Bookmark

Hybrid View

Previous Post Previous Post   Next Post Next Post
  1. #1
    Join Date
    Feb 2007
    Location
    Ireland
    Posts
    11,799
    Mentioned
    3 Post(s)
    Tagged
    0 Thread(s)
    Punch Power
    2276
    Cool Clicks

    Default Re: ? D`La Hoya vs Cotto ?...........

    Quote Originally Posted by ICB View Post
    This comment and your last comment makes no sense to me at all, first off how the hell was ODLH equal in size to Hopkins ?? ODLH was way out of his comfortable weight at Middleweight and Hopkins is naturally much bigger man than ODLH. Secondly how does ODLH wanting to fight Cotto prove ODLH is a money hungry bully ?? majority of people think Cotto would beat ODLH making ODLH the underdog. So doesn't that take bottle from ODLH wanting to take on a dangerous opponent like Cotto at this stage in his career ?? Thirdly what fighter would you want ODLH to fight at Light Middleweight that appeals to you, more than a Cotto vs ODLH fight ??
    Once again you come up with something I never said.

    I never claimed or stated that De la Hoya is equal in size to Bernard Hopkins. I may have alluded that Oscar is of a more similar build to a middleweight than the Welters and Light Welters he is calling out, but I never claimed he was equal in size to Bernard Hopkins.

    Oscar claimed last year he was the Junior Middleweight Champion of the world. A title that he won having dropped back down from Middleweight. Do you find it strange that Oscar has not faced an opponent that was previously active at 154 since 2003 when he faced Shane Mosely?
    Why not fight a Light Middleweight rather than pick on smaller me.
    For me a bully is someone who utilises their natural physical advantage to pick on opponents of a lesser physical size and obtaining an advantage befor training ever begins. Is this not what Oscar is doing?

    Any fight at 154 appeals to me more than Cotto/DLH. The Cotto DLH fight has no relevance. If DLH wins is he Welter Champion, despite having not competed against anyone in that weight class this decade? (?)
    The only relevance this has is to Oscars pockets.
    091

  2. #2
    ICB Guest

    Default Re: ? D`La Hoya vs Cotto ?...........

    Quote Originally Posted by hitmandonny View Post
    Quote Originally Posted by ICB View Post
    This comment and your last comment makes no sense to me at all, first off how the hell was ODLH equal in size to Hopkins ?? ODLH was way out of his comfortable weight at Middleweight and Hopkins is naturally much bigger man than ODLH. Secondly how does ODLH wanting to fight Cotto prove ODLH is a money hungry bully ?? majority of people think Cotto would beat ODLH making ODLH the underdog. So doesn't that take bottle from ODLH wanting to take on a dangerous opponent like Cotto at this stage in his career ?? Thirdly what fighter would you want ODLH to fight at Light Middleweight that appeals to you, more than a Cotto vs ODLH fight ??
    Once again you come up with something I never said.

    I never claimed or stated that De la Hoya is equal in size to Bernard Hopkins. I may have alluded that Oscar is of a more similar build to a middleweight than the Welters and Light Welters he is calling out, but I never claimed he was equal in size to Bernard Hopkins.

    Oscar claimed last year he was the Junior Middleweight Champion of the world. A title that he won having dropped back down from Middleweight. Do you find it strange that Oscar has not faced an opponent that was previously active at 154 since 2003 when he faced Shane Mosely?
    Why not fight a Light Middleweight rather than pick on smaller me.
    For me a bully is someone who utilises their natural physical advantage to pick on opponents of a lesser physical size and obtaining an advantage befor training ever begins. Is this not what Oscar is doing?

    Any fight at 154 appeals to me more than Cotto/DLH. The Cotto DLH fight has no relevance. If DLH wins is he Welter Champion, despite having not competed against anyone in that weight class this decade? (?)
    The only relevance this has is to Oscars pockets.
    Well you did say "Equal his size" i don't really know how i could have took that any other way. ODLH has moved up all the way up from Super Featherweight fighting bigger men than himself, so i think its wrong to call him a bully. I don't think its wrong he hasn't fought a Light Middleweight since 2003, for number of reasons, 1 he has been semi retired. 2 he was fighting Middleweight's so i think we can let him off there can't we ?? 3 there hasn't been a really appealing name at Jr Middleweight.

    Like i said to you before who do you expect ODLH to fight at Jr Middleweight ?? of course ODLH is fighting for money but so do all boxers, but there isn't a single fight at Jr Middleweight that appeals to me at all. ODLH has probably only 2 fights left in him so he wants to go out on a high, so he is looking for the biggest names. Which Jr Middleweight division just doesn't have, i can't believe that your having a go at ODLH for wanting to fight the most appealing names.

  3. #3
    Join Date
    Dec 2004
    Location
    This Lunatic Asylum
    Posts
    23,278
    Mentioned
    428 Post(s)
    Tagged
    0 Thread(s)
    Punch Power
    3124
    Cool Clicks

    Default Re: ? D`La Hoya vs Cotto ?...........

    Barring moving back up to middleweight, to fight Pavlik (ridiculous), challenging a young prime Cotto is about as DANGEROUS a fight as Oscar could take.

    It would be a tremendous show of his LOVE for boxing (he certainly doesn't need to fight) to undertake that type of challenge.

    Forget the MONEY angle, every fight Oscar has MEGA-money is attached, naturally the bigger the star in the opposite corner the more money involved.

  4. #4
    Join Date
    May 2008
    Location
    Chicago
    Posts
    247
    Mentioned
    0 Post(s)
    Tagged
    0 Thread(s)
    Punch Power
    0
    Cool Clicks

    Default Re: ? D`La Hoya vs Cotto ?...........

    Quote Originally Posted by ICB View Post
    Quote Originally Posted by hitmandonny View Post
    Quote Originally Posted by ICB View Post
    This comment and your last comment makes no sense to me at all, first off how the hell was ODLH equal in size to Hopkins ?? ODLH was way out of his comfortable weight at Middleweight and Hopkins is naturally much bigger man than ODLH. Secondly how does ODLH wanting to fight Cotto prove ODLH is a money hungry bully ?? majority of people think Cotto would beat ODLH making ODLH the underdog. So doesn't that take bottle from ODLH wanting to take on a dangerous opponent like Cotto at this stage in his career ?? Thirdly what fighter would you want ODLH to fight at Light Middleweight that appeals to you, more than a Cotto vs ODLH fight ??
    Once again you come up with something I never said.

    I never claimed or stated that De la Hoya is equal in size to Bernard Hopkins. I may have alluded that Oscar is of a more similar build to a middleweight than the Welters and Light Welters he is calling out, but I never claimed he was equal in size to Bernard Hopkins.

    Oscar claimed last year he was the Junior Middleweight Champion of the world. A title that he won having dropped back down from Middleweight. Do you find it strange that Oscar has not faced an opponent that was previously active at 154 since 2003 when he faced Shane Mosely?
    Why not fight a Light Middleweight rather than pick on smaller me.
    For me a bully is someone who utilises their natural physical advantage to pick on opponents of a lesser physical size and obtaining an advantage befor training ever begins. Is this not what Oscar is doing?

    Any fight at 154 appeals to me more than Cotto/DLH. The Cotto DLH fight has no relevance. If DLH wins is he Welter Champion, despite having not competed against anyone in that weight class this decade? (?)
    The only relevance this has is to Oscars pockets.
    Well you did say "Equal his size" i don't really know how i could have took that any other way. ODLH has moved up all the way up from Super Featherweight fighting bigger men than himself, so i think its wrong to call him a bully. I don't think its wrong he hasn't fought a Light Middleweight since 2003, for number of reasons, 1 he has been semi retired. 2 he was fighting Middleweight's so i think we can let him off there can't we ?? 3 there hasn't been a really appealing name at Jr Middleweight.

    Like i said to you before who do you expect ODLH to fight at Jr Middleweight ?? of course ODLH is fighting for money but so do all boxers, but there isn't a single fight at Jr Middleweight that appeals to me at all. ODLH has probably only 2 fights left in him so he wants to go out on a high, so he is looking for the biggest names. Which Jr Middleweight division just doesn't have, i can't believe that your having a go at ODLH for wanting to fight the most appealing names.
    In all fairness to the moving up from Super Featherweight Oscar was 19 at that time. He was not yet fully grown. Yes he fought in a grown mans sport but the body does not stop maturing until about 24 or 25 years old before it sets in at its full size potential. He was also an inch shorter then.

    This si why we rarely see fighters stay in the weight class they started in.

    Pacquiao started at 110lbs. Less I think but he was also 17 at that time. Now he is 20+lbs heavier. Having fully matured

    Since he has filled out girth wise and grown so you can not really count the Super Featherweight time as moving up. Now if he moved up at 27 or so that would be mighty impressive. In truth you would only count his time moving up from about 140lbs.

  5. #5
    ICB Guest

    Default Re: ? D`La Hoya vs Cotto ?...........

    Quote Originally Posted by Put Em' Up View Post
    Quote Originally Posted by ICB View Post
    Quote Originally Posted by hitmandonny View Post
    Once again you come up with something I never said.

    I never claimed or stated that De la Hoya is equal in size to Bernard Hopkins. I may have alluded that Oscar is of a more similar build to a middleweight than the Welters and Light Welters he is calling out, but I never claimed he was equal in size to Bernard Hopkins.

    Oscar claimed last year he was the Junior Middleweight Champion of the world. A title that he won having dropped back down from Middleweight. Do you find it strange that Oscar has not faced an opponent that was previously active at 154 since 2003 when he faced Shane Mosely?
    Why not fight a Light Middleweight rather than pick on smaller me.
    For me a bully is someone who utilises their natural physical advantage to pick on opponents of a lesser physical size and obtaining an advantage befor training ever begins. Is this not what Oscar is doing?

    Any fight at 154 appeals to me more than Cotto/DLH. The Cotto DLH fight has no relevance. If DLH wins is he Welter Champion, despite having not competed against anyone in that weight class this decade? (?)
    The only relevance this has is to Oscars pockets.
    Well you did say "Equal his size" i don't really know how i could have took that any other way. ODLH has moved up all the way up from Super Featherweight fighting bigger men than himself, so i think its wrong to call him a bully. I don't think its wrong he hasn't fought a Light Middleweight since 2003, for number of reasons, 1 he has been semi retired. 2 he was fighting Middleweight's so i think we can let him off there can't we ?? 3 there hasn't been a really appealing name at Jr Middleweight.

    Like i said to you before who do you expect ODLH to fight at Jr Middleweight ?? of course ODLH is fighting for money but so do all boxers, but there isn't a single fight at Jr Middleweight that appeals to me at all. ODLH has probably only 2 fights left in him so he wants to go out on a high, so he is looking for the biggest names. Which Jr Middleweight division just doesn't have, i can't believe that your having a go at ODLH for wanting to fight the most appealing names.
    In all fairness to the moving up from Super Featherweight Oscar was 19 at that time. He was not yet fully grown. Yes he fought in a grown mans sport but the body does not stop maturing until about 24 or 25 years old before it sets in at its full size potential. He was also an inch shorter then.

    This si why we rarely see fighters stay in the weight class they started in.

    Pacquiao started at 110lbs. Less I think but he was also 17 at that time. Now he is 20+lbs heavier. Having fully matured

    Since he has filled out girth wise and grown so you can not really count the Super Featherweight time as moving up. Now if he moved up at 27 or so that would be mighty impressive. In truth you would only count his time moving up from about 140lbs.
    Your missing the point thats not what i was implying, i was trying to explain how ODLH has moved through the weight classes fighting bigger men than himself, so i just think its wrong to call him a bully.

    Also good post Fenster some rep coming your way.

  6. #6
    Join Date
    May 2008
    Location
    Chicago
    Posts
    247
    Mentioned
    0 Post(s)
    Tagged
    0 Thread(s)
    Punch Power
    0
    Cool Clicks

    Default Re: ? D`La Hoya vs Cotto ?...........

    Quote Originally Posted by ICB View Post
    Quote Originally Posted by Put Em' Up View Post
    Quote Originally Posted by ICB View Post

    Well you did say "Equal his size" i don't really know how i could have took that any other way. ODLH has moved up all the way up from Super Featherweight fighting bigger men than himself, so i think its wrong to call him a bully. I don't think its wrong he hasn't fought a Light Middleweight since 2003, for number of reasons, 1 he has been semi retired. 2 he was fighting Middleweight's so i think we can let him off there can't we ?? 3 there hasn't been a really appealing name at Jr Middleweight.

    Like i said to you before who do you expect ODLH to fight at Jr Middleweight ?? of course ODLH is fighting for money but so do all boxers, but there isn't a single fight at Jr Middleweight that appeals to me at all. ODLH has probably only 2 fights left in him so he wants to go out on a high, so he is looking for the biggest names. Which Jr Middleweight division just doesn't have, i can't believe that your having a go at ODLH for wanting to fight the most appealing names.
    In all fairness to the moving up from Super Featherweight Oscar was 19 at that time. He was not yet fully grown. Yes he fought in a grown mans sport but the body does not stop maturing until about 24 or 25 years old before it sets in at its full size potential. He was also an inch shorter then.

    This si why we rarely see fighters stay in the weight class they started in.

    Pacquiao started at 110lbs. Less I think but he was also 17 at that time. Now he is 20+lbs heavier. Having fully matured

    Since he has filled out girth wise and grown so you can not really count the Super Featherweight time as moving up. Now if he moved up at 27 or so that would be mighty impressive. In truth you would only count his time moving up from about 140lbs.
    Your missing the point thats not what i was implying, i was trying to explain how ODLH has moved through the weight classes fighting bigger men than himself, so i just think its wrong to call him a bully.

    Also good post Fenster some rep coming your way.
    \Who has Oscar really fought bigger then him? Except for guys at MW. I mean that in a sincere way not to start any type of trouble.

    Oscar is 5'10 1/2" about an inch taller then when he started out so he would have been 5' 9 1/2" then.

    Jimmy Bredahl 5'8" DLH wins WBO title.

    Jorge Paez 5'5", John John Molina 5'7" , Jessie James Leija 5'5" Rafael Ruelas 5'11" (By this time DLH had grown into his frame more and for the fight he was listed at 5' 10") , Julio Cesar Chavez 5' 7 1/2", Pernell Whitiker 5'6", Miguel Angel Gonzalez 5'8", Felix Trinidad and Wilfredo Rivera both 5'11".

    Gatti, Mosley all smaller then Oscar. Vargas shorter but stockier. Mayweather and Forbes both smaller. Sturm had him by an inch both weighed the same. Hopkins is the only opponent he ever faced with a visible and genuine size difference though they weighed the same.

    Also during Oscars SFW,LW years he held the reach advantage 90% of the time.

    Sorry ICB but Oscar did not fight bigger men those years he was always a big man for those division. The tale of the tape does not lie

  7. #7
    Join Date
    Jan 2008
    Posts
    1,394
    Mentioned
    0 Post(s)
    Tagged
    0 Thread(s)
    Punch Power
    1246
    Cool Clicks

    Default Re: ? D`La Hoya vs Cotto ?...........

    Hey Put Em Up , i really like your P4P Best Chicken my friend.........

  8. #8
    Join Date
    May 2008
    Location
    Chicago
    Posts
    247
    Mentioned
    0 Post(s)
    Tagged
    0 Thread(s)
    Punch Power
    0
    Cool Clicks

    Default Re: ? D`La Hoya vs Cotto ?...........

    Quote Originally Posted by Macho View Post
    Hey Put Em Up , i really like your P4P Best Chicken my friend.........
    Ha Ha ha. Danny G put it up yesterday as a joke to see if anyone would use it as a sig so I took him up on the offer lol.

    I will use it for a week or so then take it off. It really has nothing to do as far as me hating Mayweather as much as I find it to be FUNNY!

  9. #9
    Join Date
    Feb 2007
    Location
    Ireland
    Posts
    11,799
    Mentioned
    3 Post(s)
    Tagged
    0 Thread(s)
    Punch Power
    2276
    Cool Clicks

    Default Re: ? D`La Hoya vs Cotto ?...........

    Quote Originally Posted by ICB View Post
    Well you did say "Equal his size" i don't really know how i could have took that any other way. ODLH has moved up all the way up from Super Featherweight fighting bigger men than himself, so i think its wrong to call him a bully. I don't think its wrong he hasn't fought a Light Middleweight since 2003, for number of reasons, 1 he has been semi retired. 2 he was fighting Middleweight's so i think we can let him off there can't we ?? 3 there hasn't been a really appealing name at Jr Middleweight.

    Like i said to you before who do you expect ODLH to fight at Jr Middleweight ?? of course ODLH is fighting for money but so do all boxers, but there isn't a single fight at Jr Middleweight that appeals to me at all. ODLH has probably only 2 fights left in him so he wants to go out on a high, so he is looking for the biggest names. Which Jr Middleweight division just doesn't have, i can't believe that your having a go at ODLH for wanting to fight the most appealing names.
    Well I do believe that Hopkins was a lot nearer in size to De la Hoya than Forbes is

    When Oscar embarked on his professional career he was 19, he had a lot of growing up and filling out to do and as he did he moved up, he never moved up and fought someone larger apart from the Sturm and Hopkins fights, which were both actual losses.
    1)"Semi retired"
    This is not a legitimate excuse. Does a semi retired doctor only half treat ill people?
    As long as a boxer remains in the sport they should apply themselves properly.

    2)He was beaten by Middleweights and despite calling himself the WBC 154 Chamoion last year has fought no 154 men??

    3)Winky Wright.

    Oscar is selecting all smaller fighters. He's called out Jatton, from 140 (granted he weighed 143 for his last fight,) Forbes, beaten at both 140 and 130. Mayorga was coming up from 147, Floyd was coming up from 147, he had plenty of offers from guys at 154.....Spinks, Forrest, Mora....hey Winky's mentioned him for years!!!

    Oscar as far as I'm concerned is a bully until he faces a man his own size again. But he probably will not as he's past his prime and I think lacks confidence in his reduced physical strength and speed.
    091

Thread Information

Users Browsing this Thread

There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)

     

Similar Threads

  1. Why Cotto-Dela Hoya is good for Cotto-Mayweather
    By Taeth in forum Boxing Talk
    Replies: 12
    Last Post: 12-16-2007, 03:52 PM
  2. De La Hoya on fighting Cotto
    By bikersk in forum Boxing Talk
    Replies: 12
    Last Post: 11-12-2007, 08:29 PM
  3. Cotto/De La Hoya?
    By SigmaMu in forum Boxing Talk
    Replies: 11
    Last Post: 11-11-2007, 05:11 PM
  4. Will Cotto be fighting De La Hoya??
    By Puerto Rican Punch in forum Boxing Talk
    Replies: 9
    Last Post: 08-12-2007, 04:08 PM
  5. Replies: 23
    Last Post: 04-20-2007, 06:39 PM

Tags for this Thread

Bookmarks

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •  




Boxing | Boxing Photos | Boxing News | Boxing Forum | Boxing Rankings

Copyright © 2000 - 2025 Saddo Boxing - Boxing