Boxrec make JMM No1 Lightweight. Who agrees?

[leftylee]

Hey Lefty, I take it you don't rate Hatton no.1 at 140 then?

Holt (WBO), Bradley (WBC), Kotelnik (WBA), Powderpuff (IBF)

Hatton is only The Ring champion

Hatton is the Lineal champ and has been number 1 in the division for 3 years. EVERYBODY knows Hatton is number 1 at Jr-welterweight, even the haters. He had to give up the IBF and WBA belts. He didn't lose them in the ring.

Right. So why is Casamayor different? He beat Diego Corrales to become lineal champ and hadn't lost until Marquez. Simple as. Like Hatton, Casa didn't need the shiny belts to PROVE he was the man.

Casamayor is different because many people considered him number 2 in the division behind Juan Diaz and when Campbell beat Diaz people thought he was behind Nate Campbell.

Nobody thought Witter or Paulie was above Hatton only Witter and Paulie themselves and we all know how both of them are up there own asses.

Hatton was the clear number 1 while Casamayor wasn't. Many people begged to differ at Joel.