Who was better....

[CutMeMick]

That's a thread in and of itself. I don't get how so many people can rate Duran so damn high on the all time p4p lists. On the basis of what? his time at lightweight? HIs badass image? Would you rate Duran higher than Arguello? Higher than Chavez? There are a number of fighters who have more victories against big names than Duran. Fighters who have had far more success moving up through the divisions. Who's the biggest name Duran has a +record against? Iknow Duran is good, but he aint that good. IMHO

As for the P4P question here's my all time P4P list.
I should say my most recent P4P list because it changes a bit as time passes and I learn more about boxers.

All of the lists I make, I base them of fighters I've seen myself with my own eyes.
I refuse to list ANY fighter whom I have not seen any fights of and have ONLY read things about. Which is why you will never see me list Saddler, Benny, Loughran, Greb etc. etc. etc. because the footage I've seen if any has been very limited.

1. SRR
2. Ali
3. Armstrong
4. Duran
5. Alexis
6. SRL
7. Pernell
8. JCC
9. Monzon
10. "Finito" Lopez

[bambamdaddio]

That's a thread in and of itself. I don't get how so many people can rate Duran so damn high on the all time p4p lists. On the basis of what? his time at lightweight? HIs badass image? Would you rate Duran higher than Arguello? Higher than Chavez? There are a number of fighters who have more victories against big names than Duran. Fighters who have had far more success moving up through the divisions. Who's the biggest name Duran has a +record against? Iknow Duran is good, but he aint that good. IMHO

As for the P4P question here's my all time P4P list.
I should say my most recent P4P list because it changes a bit as time passes and I learn more about boxers.

All of the lists I make, I base them of fighters I've seen myself with my own eyes.
I refuse to list ANY fighter whom I have not seen any fights of and have ONLY read things about. Which is why you will never see me list Saddler, Benny, Loughran, Greb etc. etc. etc. because the footage I've seen if any has been very limited.

1. SRR
2. Ali
3. Armstrong
4. Duran
5. Alexis
6. SRL
7. Pernell
8. JCC
9. Monzon
10. "Finito" Lopez

A very wise post bud ...