Top 100 All-Time Greats: Post your list here...

[JonesJrMayweather]

Well I'll try based only off what ive seen for myself and not what i've been told....

1- SRR
2- RJJ
3- PERNELL
4- SSM
5- PBF
6- ALI
7- LOUIS
8- Barerra
9- lennox
10- SRL
11- holyfield
12- TONEY
13- bhop
14- oscar


this is impossible...havent seen enough of the older guys their fights are hard to come by not to mention the only ones people put up are of them winning. So i used my list based the fighters who i've seen the most of..and even though ive seen fights on the other guys like duran,pep,armstrong, saddler, moore, chavez, ezzard, greb, fitz,

i haven't seen enough to personally rate them high. and i don't go off what the old historians say because they're biased towards the old era guys anyway.

[iwng100]

.................................................. .
i haven't seen enough to personally rate them high. and i don't go off what the old historians say because they're biased towards the old era guys anyway.

I totally agree, you took the words from my mouth actually.

[fan johnny]

All list are subjective. For anyone that does not know the meaning of the word, here is the explanation Subjectivity - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Every list is going to be an opinion that is subjective. If I were to pick a fight that was a legitimate draw and I'd follow one fighter more than the other, I most likely would pick the fighter I followed as the winner. Example: Marquez / Pacquiao I.

I would be interested in seeing a comprehensive list that was based on a point system like BoxRec Ratings Description - Boxrec Boxing Encyclopaedia

There are things to consider that can only be subjective. They are not calculated into Boxrec's formula i.e. When fighters go past their prime and a lesser fighter wins. When a fighter fails to defend his title against other top rated fighters. When a fight is killed in the ring... (nah... forget that one) Fighters may have had injuries or had been weight drained. Anyway you get the point...

[josef4334]

100 is too many. try counting 100 pennies and you'll say "fak it" after counting penny #43. top 15 maybe.

[The Fightfan]

Ray Robinson one hundred times

[AdamGB]

100 is too many. try counting 100 pennies and you'll say "fak it" after counting penny #43. top 15 maybe.

You're lucky, you've obviously never had to cash a till up!

[josef4334]

100 is too many. try counting 100 pennies and you'll say "fak it" after counting penny #43. top 15 maybe.

You're lucky, you've obviously never had to cash a till up!

nah man.. i bring them coins to be counted at commerce bank.. its free you know.

[Mr140]

Well i making a list of fighter form 1978-2009 because after that i really have not seen or watch enough of them my list is based on what they did in that time frame please feel free to add any names you think are not there and should be let it be known i do not know the lower weight well.

1Sugar Ray Leonard
2Tommey Hearns
3Roberto Duran
4Pernell Whitcker
5Marvin Hagler
6Ricardo Lopez
7Julio Ceasar Chavez
8Azuma Nelson
9Salvador Sanchaz
10Shane Moseley
11.Roy Jones Jr
12.Floyde Mayweather
13.Oscar Dela Hoya
14.Lennox Lewis
15.Evander Holyfeild
16. Bernard Hopkins
17. Micheal Spinks
18.Winkey Wright
19. Welfred Benitez

alot of names i missed out on there and yea i know i still working on were i want to place them i keep working on its going to take me long time and it while look different by the time i am done but throw names out there and also tell me were you feel that fighter should be also it while help.

[BIG H]

This aint in order, but it's some great names that I could think of. I will have missed loads off.

Sugar Ray Robinson
Henry Armstrong
Willie Pepp
Muhammad Ali
Roberto Duran
Jimmy Wilde
Benny Leonard
Pernell Whitaker
Sandy Saddler
Sugar Ray Leonard
Roy Jones Jnr
Sammy Langford
Ricardo Lopez
Charlie Burley
Marvin Hagler
Julio Cesar Chavez
Carlos Monzon
Marco Antonio Barerra
Harry Greb
Archie Moore
Gene Tunney
Larry Holmes
Aaron Pryor
Erik Morales
Eder Jofre
Joe Louis
Ezzard Charles
Alexis Arguello
Floyd Mayweather Junior
Billy Conn
Bernard Hopkins

[Taeth]

I have always said the ATG system has been terrible because historians have to idolize the past it happens in every sport, it happens in every subject. The past hyperbolized to the point legend becomes "reality"

That being said I will still try make the best list I can with help from Bert Sugar and his views of some guys that came before my time and before they had extensive clips of fighters. I mean regardless of him being a crackpot, he definitely talked to guys who saw these people fight, and he definitely saw a lot of these guys most haven't seen fight.

[Mr140]

Think you should try to get like say 20 greats form each era then try to form it but some are tough because we have never seen them fight.

[CutMeMick]

I would be interested in seeing a comprehensive list that was based on a point system like BoxRec Ratings Description - Boxrec Boxing Encyclopaedia

You serious? There is nothing comprehensive about their sys.
BoxRec has got THEE worst rating system ever created.

[fan johnny]

I would be interested in seeing a comprehensive list that was based on a point system like BoxRec Ratings Description - Boxrec Boxing Encyclopaedia

You serious? There is nothing comprehensive about their sys.
BoxRec has got THEE worst rating system ever created.

The ONLY reason to disrespect a system of facts is to distort TRUTH

[Phil]

Britkid did his top 100 90's

http://www.saddoboxing.com/boxingfor...p-100-90s.html

and 80's

http://www.saddoboxing.com/boxingfor...hters-80s.html

[BIG H]

Good find mate - I was going to look for those earlier