Cotto vs Chop Chop Corley

[AdamGB]

It's sorta funny how before Dirrell fought Froch people brought up how he was knocked down in his 7th pro fight as evidence of a suspect chin. But if someone brings up the Corley Cotto fight in terms of him being stunned people will say it was a while ago and it doesnt count now

Apples and Oranges.

I don't recall dirrel ever moving up a weight class? He's always been comfortable at Super Middle.

[The Boxer]

Majesty i understand exactly where your comming from. People often bring up how chop chop hurt PBF as evidence of how PBF can't take a punch But when you mention chop chop hurting Cotto people act like it was forever ago. If i do recall PBF fought Chop CHop in 04 and Cotto fought him in 05. Also Cotto was way more hurt than by Chop than PBF was. People tried to use the chop chop fight as evidence that PBF couldn't handle the strength of fighters at 140 and above. Now all of a sudden people act like PBF is Paul Williams. Anyway all i'm saying is if you wanna use PBF Corley which was in 2004 than we should be able to use Corely Cotto which was in 2005.

By the way whats Chop Chop doing anyway. I haven't heard from him since the Writter fight which i still haven't seen.

[Pugilistic]

Cotto was seriously weight drained at 140.

Look at Cotto at his weigh in against Corley.



Ever since moving up to 147 his chin has proved to be pretty solid taking shots from the likes of Judah, Clottey, Mosley, Quintana. Even against Margarito he took alot of punishment to the body and head before he went down.

[AdamGB]

I think that picture says it all really...

Like I said before: Unless you're comparing two physically identical fighters under the exact same circumstances then you're basically comparing chalk and cheese or apples and oranges.

We're talking about boxing here boys, not playing with pokemon cards.

[Jimanuel Boogustus]

Cotto was seriously weight drained at 140.

Look at Cotto at his weigh in against Corley.



Ever since moving up to 147 his chin has proved to be pretty solid taking shots from the likes of Judah, Clottey, Mosley, Quintana. Even against Margarito he took alot of punishment to the body and head before he went down.

Nice one Pugilistic, Thats the pic i was looking for...!

Anyone care to say Cotto isn't just a bit dehydrated here