Skip to content
Saddo Boxing News
  • Home
  • Boxing Forum
  • Boxing Videos
  • Contact
Saddo Boxing News
Boxing Articles

The Five All Time Worst Boxing Decisions

ByDavid Shipman 13/05/2009

This article is meant to be contrasted as only opinion, but there is more to it. This writer will explore the tale-of-the-tape, the circumstances and how it went down, who deserved to win, and most importantly, why.

This will only cover modern-era fights, mainly between 1980’s until now, because one can simply not find enough material to sift through and cover. Now, for the moment you have been waiting for…

Number 5:
Jose Luis Castillo vs Floyd Mayweather, Jr. I, 2002. Result: Mayweather, Jr. 116-111, 115-111 and115-111. What should have happened: Mayweather picked up the first three rounds easy on all scorecards, but hurt his hand. Castillo used amazing tactics and bullied Mayweather to the ropes, he began to score at will with his left hook. He even muscled Mayweather, hit him with a barrage of good body shots and began to close the gap.

I had Mayweather losing rounds 4-7 and rounds 8 through 11. This equals out to 115-111 for Castillo. Castillo should be applauded for not giving up his title through selling his “soul” to promoters. This is arguably Mayweather’s first loss. Mayweather would eventually “school” Castillo in the rematch. Although the judges had it 115-113, 116-113 and 116-113, many pundits scored the rematch 117-111 for Mayweather.

Number 4:
Pernell Whitaker vs Oscar De La Hoya, 1997. Result: A commanding five and six-point decision win for De La Hoya despite suffering a knockdown. What should have happened: De La Hoya began to get jabbed and hit from all angles. The pro-De La Hoya crowd never helped Whitaker. Whitaker lacked knockout power and charisma, but was a Hall-of-Fame boxer. Whitaker would eventually score a questionable knockdown in the 9th, but ultimately De La Hoya landed just enough flurries at the end of rounds to sway the judges.

I actually had Whitaker winning eight of the twelve rounds for a 116-112 score. The two would never fight again.
Whitaker slipped in to drug addiction, leaving many to ponder what would have been if he would have fought Felix Trinidad healthy? On that segue….

Number 3:
Oscar De La Hoya vs Felix Trinidad, 1999. Result: Trinidad wins by MD 12, 115-113, 114-114 and 115-113. What should have happened: Correct math by “intelligent” judges. Oscar De La Hoya put on a “boxing show” as he put it for the first seven-plus rounds. De La Hoya was up six rounds to one after seven, then won the eighth with ripping combinations that had Trinidad’s shorts bloody.

De La Hoya would tire in the late rounds and some accused him of “running”. Trinidad didn’t really land anything significant but still managed to win the fight and went onto become a destructive cyborg in higher weight divisions. Saving grace: De La Hoya would be the first to lay out a “plan” to beat Trinidad. Hopkins used the same strategy and thus dominated Trinidad in September, 2001.

Number 2:
Pernell Whitaker vs Jose Luis Ramirez, I, 1988. Result: Ramirez wins by SD, 113-117, 118-113 and 116-115. Some of the most outlandish scores ever reported. Let’s put this into context. These scores mean that there were many “10-10” rounds and the scores were severely front-loaded. What should have happened: A clear-cut UD win for Whitaker.

Whitaker landed superb shots and even was able to humiliate Ramirez. Two of the judges were of Mexican descent. But Whitaker would be handed his first loss and had to wait to exact his revenge on Ramirez in the states. Whitaker did exactly that, winning 10 of the 12 rounds in beating Ramirez during a rematch for the lightweight title.

Number 1:
Whitaker has the dubious decision of appearing on the countdown three times. Pernell Whitaker vs Julio Cesar Chavez, 1993. Result: 115-113 (Whitaker), 115-115, 115-115. Chavez entered the fight at 87-0. He was equivalent to “Mr. Dream” in “Punch Out”, in fact, that was him, right? This is perhaps Whitaker’s most culminating achievement. To outclass Chavez, who was seen on a different stratosphere and he did just that.

I remember I was 10-years-old and watching the fight thinking ‘when was Chavez was going to knock him out’? It was evident by round seven that Whitaker had his number. Whitaker would go into a low crouch and nail Chavez to the body. He again would step inside and fire beautiful combinations that had Chavez off-balance most of the night.

Based on his stature, I only gave Chavez three rounds. In what would have been a classic fight, if not for the horrible decision, I rank this as the worst of the past 25 years of boxing. It should have been 117-111 across the board.

Whitaker has had the dubious distinction of being the only fighter ripped off as many times as he did. He retired with a record of 40-4-1. In reality, it should have been 42-1-1 with the only loss being to Trinidad. The Roy Jones before there was one was wronged by judges and faulty promoters throughout his career.

Post Tags: #Felix Trinidad#Floyd Mayweather Jr#Jose Luis Castillo#Jose Luis Ramirez#Julio Cesar Chavez#Oscar De La Hoya#Pernell Whitaker

Post navigation

Previous Previous
Ringside Boxing Report: Dave Ryan vs Scott Evans
NextContinue
Crown Boxing: McCall vs. Hopoate For IBA Title In Las Vegas May 22

Boxing Site Team

Owner/Webmaster:
Saddo 📧

Site Photographer:
Jane Warburton 📷
Site Writers:
(Click name to view all that writer’s work)
  • Curtis McCormick
  • Nick Chamberlain
  • Jose Espinoza
  • Robert Brizel
  • Richard Eberline
  • Danny Wilson
  • Bruce Dingo
  • Alejandro Tostado
  • Ricky Jones
  • Wellington Amadulu


RSS Feed

RSS Boxing Forum

  • Lauren Price vs Michaela Kotaskova headlines Cardiff card 18/11/2026
    Originally published at: Lauren Price vs Michaela Kotaskova headlines Cardiff card Lauren Price headlines a welterweight card against Michaela Kotaskova, with Rhys Edwards vs Lee McGregor and Willy Gilheaney vs Alberto Palmetta among the key fights. 16 posts - 3 participants Read full topic […]
  • Amari Jones vs DeAundre Pettus Preview: Can Jones Stay Unbeaten? 18/11/2026
    Originally published at: Amari Jones vs DeAundre Pettus Preview: Can Jones Stay Unbeaten? Amari Jones meets DeAundre Pettus in the main event, with Gabriela Fundora vs Jasmina Zapotoczna leading a busy DAZN card from California. 4 posts - 2 participants Read full topic […]
  • Wilder v Opetaia is OFF 18/11/2026
    Well, Wilder will need another opponent after Jai Opetaia has opted to pull out of the fight.. Dan Rafeal explains a bit of it. DAN RAFAEL REVEALS SHOCK DETAILS ON WHY JAI OPETAIA PULLED OUT OF DEONTAY WILDER FIGHT 8 posts - 6 participants Read full topic […]
  • Teremoana Teremoana vs Hemi Ahio Preview: Heavyweight Power Meets Experience in Melbourne 17/11/2026
    Originally published at: Teremoana Teremoana vs Hemi Ahio Preview: Heavyweight Power Meets Experience in Melbourne Teremoana Teremoana faces Hemi Ahio in Melbourne on November 18, 2026. Full heavyweight fight preview, analysis and undercard featuring Camilleri vs Leek. 10 posts - 4 participants Read full topic […]
  • Jorge Linares detained by ICE 17/11/2026
    Former three-weight world champion Jorge Linares says he has been detained by US immigration authorities in Texas. The 41-year-old Venezuelan posted a message on social media on Sunday about being held by America’s Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) agency. Linares is based in Miami and has fought more than 10 times in America. “ICE has me at the Texa […]
  • Old classic scrap I just found- Mckinney v Jones 14/11/2026
    I happened to stumble upon a short but excellent super bantamweight classic war between Kennedy McKinney vs Junior Jones for the WBO title at that weight. I didn’t know it was such a short-war and a classic little scrap. That is worth every second of those four rounds. lolol… JUNIOR JONES VS KENNEDY MCKINNEY 12 posts - 4 participants Read full topic […]
  • Diego Pacheco vs Darius Fulghum Preview: Unbeaten Super Middleweight Faces a Serious Test 13/11/2026
    Originally published at: Diego Pacheco vs Darius Fulghum Preview: Unbeaten Super Middleweight Faces a Serious Test Diego Pacheco faces Darius Fulghum in a WBA super middleweight eliminator on November 14. Full fight preview, records and undercard analysis. 31 posts - 4 participants Read full topic […]
  • Carlos Adames vs Gerome Warburton Preview: Zuffa Boxing 13 Heads to Riyadh 13/11/2026
    Originally published at: Carlos Adames vs Gerome Warburton Preview: Zuffa Boxing 13 Heads to Riyadh Carlos Adames faces Gerome Warburton in Riyadh on November 14. Full Zuffa Boxing 13 preview, including Moloney vs Teran and the complete undercard. 16 posts - 4 participants Read full topic […]
  • Viddal Riley vs Seydi Coupe Preview: Unbeaten Cruiserweights Collide on DAZN 13/11/2026
    Originally published at: Viddal Riley vs Seydi Coupe Preview: Unbeaten Cruiserweights Collide on DAZN Viddal Riley defends his European cruiserweight title against unbeaten Seydi Coupe on November 14. Preview, prediction and full DAZN undercard including Barrett vs Gwynne. 10 posts - 3 participants Read full topic […]
  • Bryan Flores vs Jose Nunez Preview: Unbeaten Records Under Threat on ProBox TV in El Paso 13/11/2026
    Originally published at: Bryan Flores vs Jose Nunez Preview: Unbeaten Records Under Threat on ProBox TV in El Paso Bryan Flores faces unbeaten Jose Nunez in El Paso on November 13. Full ProBox TV fight preview, including Erdenebat vs Yaqubov and the undercard. 3 posts - 2 participants Read full topic […]
  • Jaron ennis v Josh Kelly February 27th 11/11/2026
    4 posts - 3 participants Read full topic […]
  • Is Teddy Atlas "overrated?" 10/11/2026
    Is he? is he just a lot of hot air and his boxing takes are full of gibberish? i never was head over heels about Atlas, to be honest. I find him to be someone who is just a part of the fraternity of the sport, and not some wise sage like Manny Steward or even a Stacey McKinkley- who is really wise in the sport. What is your take on Atlas? Just a loudmouth wi […]
  • Nelson Asofa-Solomona vs Paul Gallen | Full Fight | No Limit Boxing | 📅 Nov 6, 2026 06/11/2026
    Originally published at: Nelson Asofa-Solomona vs Paul Gallen | Full Fight | No Limit Boxing | 📅 Nov 6, 2026 Watch all the action, knockdowns and post-fight reaction from one of the biggest nights in Australian boxing. Tik Tok Arena, Sydney Nov 6, 2026 No Limit Boxing Subscribe for more fight highlights, behind-the-scenes content and everything No Limit Boxi […]
  • Joshua Buatsi vs Willy Hutchinson 2: Full Card Preview 06/11/2026
    Originally published at: Joshua Buatsi vs Willy Hutchinson 2: Full Card Preview Joshua Buatsi and Willy Hutchinson meet again for the vacant WBC light-heavyweight title, with Jack Rafferty vs Hovhannes Martirosyan and the full undercard on DAZN. 21 posts - 3 participants Read full topic […]
  • Devin haney v liam paro december 19th 05/11/2026
    2 posts - 2 participants Read full topic […]

© 2026 Saddo Boxing News

  • Home
  • Boxing Forum
  • Boxing Videos
  • Contact