Quote Originally Posted by CutMeMick View Post
- Nonito although he holds a win over Vic, Vic wasn't P4P when Nonito beat him so you cant use that as a reason.
- Vic beat a P4P fighter in Mijares so he goes above.
Quote Originally Posted by Julius Rain View Post
I dont know mick, just cause vic beat mijares his above nonito and now a p4pder? I know vic dominated mijares but IMO if nonito and vic fought again. vic wouldn't win a single round again and would get knocked out again. I think both Nonito and Montiel are above vic. As good as we think Mijares is, we still gotta consider how good Nonito and MOntiel is too. If Mijares was clearly the superior fighter over Nonito and MOntiel then yea I may agree with you. Mijares is not though and has not proven much except his win over arce who I think is as overrated as vic is. IMO the nonito montiel showdown is the biggest match below 130 since rafa izzy 3.
See above...
If you honestly feel Mijares was being overrated then by any means feel that way. But I can tell you he's not.
Every dog has it's day and that's how I see that fight.
The same way Vic was sparked out, now Mijares was.
Then one day someone will come along and beat Nonito.
Mijares had a shitty day but hey at least it came to the hands of someone like Vic who seems to be wrecking havoc as of late.
He's beat Gorres (in my book), Kirilov & Mijares.
Nonito might be better then Vic & Mijares and who knows even better then Montiel.
My point is Mijares was P4P top 10 when he was beat by Vic.
When Nonito beat Vic, Vic was no where near P4P.

When compiling the list I looked at Nonitos resume and his inactivity plus opposition hurt him compared to the rest. I just didn't look at skills.

If I put Nonito above Vic, then that would mean I'd have to list Ricardo Cordoba who holds a win over Caballero and is now a title holder. But again I can't cause the win over Caballero came yrs. ago before Caballero was rated this high.